I am a former wwcg member from approx. 1985 to the nineties. (not
exactly sure as confusion seemed to cloud my mind after the death of
HWA. My experience is a bit different from many of you that grew up in
the church or spent many years there. I should say that I appreciate the
work you are doing. It is painful for me to see the allegations about
HWA on your site, but even though today is the first inkling I have ever
had of much of this, I can see that it is most likely accurate. I had
already figured out on my own that he was deluded on certain subjects
and greatly enjoyed the prestige and high life of his office but blamed
others in my mind for encouraging his human nature. (Those like Gerald
Waterhouse with his wild eyed predictions and numerology nonsense and
carrying on about the prophetic significance of everything Armstrong)
But, until today I did not think that he had consciously deceived us. A
sad day.
I, unlike many of the victims testifying here, was raised SDA. In
that cult we were taught that their prophetess, Ellen G White, received
direct revelations from God. She wrote 65 books and I grew up in Takoma
Park, MD (world headquarters for the adventists) and my father (a
second generation SDA) was a florist with his flower shop directly
across the street from the Takoma Park SDA church AND directly across
the street from the General Conference of Seventh Day Adventists (world
headquarters) AND directly across the street from the Review and Herald
publishing company. The world headquarters publishing company of the
SDA’s.
I grew up in that flower shop. It had a huge Hallmark card section
which brought in all the SDA employees and executives on a regular
basis. I was well known and knew many of the leaders of the church. I
placed the flowers in front of the podium every Sabbath morning. My dad
taught Sabbath school. I was baptized several times. I sang solos in
front of hundreds. I attended SDA schools and studied the bible and
Ellen White daily. I took it all quite seriously. I read most of EG
Whites books and believed all they said. My family and I sat front and
center in the Takoma Park church every Sabbath.
I was an intellectual child in spite of my devotion to the “truth”.
The sermons were usually incredibly boring and all I had to read were
the church hymnal and the Bible. After wearing out the hymnal to escape
the boredom I began reading the old testament. The kings and such
historical parts were pretty boring to me and the psalms didn’t do
anything for me and then I discovered Solomon’s writings. I read about
how Solomon choose wisdom and understanding over all else, when offered
anything he desired, and was thrilled by that. In my childish innocence,
I was about twelve, I bowed my head right there and prayed for the same
things. Whether or not there is a God or if he answers prayers, this is
a powerful thing.
After that I began reading Isaiah and other latter prophets and
trying to figure out what in the world they were talking about! In SDA
doctrine we never heard anything about a peaceful world, only heaven and
lakes of fire. I began questioning ministers in the church and because
of my family’s position I was able to question the higher up’s and talk
to Ellen White’s heirs and others the average member did not have access
to. I was given the usual double speak and told the the unconditional
promises of the old testament and the prophecies of a peaceful just
world were the “way it would have been if Israel had obeyed God.” They
had convinced me that the Bible was God’s word so they laid the
groundwork for my rejection of the church. Eventually the “White Lie”
came out. (The facts the Ellen White copied much or all of her writings
from earlier protestant writers, how easy it was to get away with before
the internet!)
I was through, and extremely angry. I was really pissed off for
years, but had not lost my faith in the Bible as the word of God so was
easy pickings for WWCG. When I first heard HWA in the 80′s I had to
drive to the top of a mountain in WV where I was living to get the
station clearly. The reason I did was because what he was saying finally
made sense of all the things I had read in Isaiah and elsewhere and
never could make any sense of. JW’s were too weird so I couldn’t get it
from them. HWA made sense of it and I determined to disprove him because
of the deception I had experienced with EG White. I read every
scripture he quoted and the context on either side of it to disprove
what he was teaching and found that he was teaching scripturally sound
doctrine. (I was used to total inexplicable fantasies like most
protestant religions use).
The more I tried to prove him wrong, the more I proved him
scripturally correct. I was hooked, line and sinker. I dragged my family
along and joined the church. Gave them a lot of money just like the
rest of you. I am now divorced and I can’t say it is the fault of the
church but I am not sure. Our life was significantly altered and it is
possible that the church life prevented us from developing a healthy
relationship. I generally blame myself but don’t we all, and not
necessarily correctly. I guess I am rambling on but it is such a relief
to find a group of folks that have some similar experiences.
For years I have wanted to get in touch with former members that were
with us through all that but could not find them as I had moved away
and left the church. Couldn’t help but wonder what their thoughts and
experiences were since the dissolution of the church, the Joseph T
debacle and all. Didn’t even know about all this HWA stuff but it makes
sense now in retrospect. I have read most every page on your site today
and I have noticed that there are multiple “moderators” and some seem to
be atheistic or at least agnostic, while others seem to be somewhat
still open to scripture being possibly authentic.
I admire the attitude of all here and cannot begin to understand what
some of you experienced in the old days before standards were somewhat
relaxed as they were in my time in the church. I do have a clue though.
Because of all that I have been through I have been compelled to write
out my thoughts and beliefs and to publish them online in the delusional
imagination that I understood all as I prayed for at 12. I had a site
called the plain truth.info for a few years. This exercise taught me a
lot and writing out your thoughts and beliefs is a great way to examine
your beliefs as I found myself constantly having to correct myself.
To me the conclusions that I derived from this several year exercise
has been helpful and comforting. I don’t know if it would be of any
interest or profit to anyone but it has been to me and so I include it
here just in case.
I could not let go of the belief that the Scripture was inspired, (a
teaching I received in the SDA church that led me to leave it) only that
I had been fooled again. In the WWCG I had finally been able to
understand all the things that drove me crazy in the SDA in the
“inspired” word. I realized that HWA was somewhat deceived and that the
WWCG was not the “TRUE CHURCH.” I did not, of course know the rest of
the story. After Joe Tkach I left in disgust. It’s funny, the teachings
of the SDA’s caused me to disbelieve them, AND the teachings of HWA
caused me to disbelieve him too.
In my analysis on my plain truth site I first reasoned that belief
systems were choices that serve us or not and that none of them are
provable. Creationist, atheist, or whatever is you choose, you can’t
prove it’s true. It’s just your choice and as an automatic side effect
of your choice you MUST discredit/disprove (to your satisfaction)
opposing views. I chose the belief that was hammered into me, that
scripture was inspired BUT, I had actually been thinking for myself for
some time and came to a different view than I have seen expressed
anywhere else.
1. “Scripture” means the Hebrew “old testament”. That was what Christ said could not be broken.
2. The “new testament” was canonized by the Catholic church but has
been accepted as “the word of God” by virtually all groups, even those
(such as the WWCG) that see the Catholic church as the Great Whore. It
seems that it never crosses anyone’s mind to question the validity of
this document and every word, especially Paul’s, is given reverence as
God’s utterances. This is plainly naive.
At best, if we can trust that the works are genuine, the four
“gospels” are not “scripture” they are eyewitness accounts and hearsay
of the life and acts of Christ as recalled by his companions/disciples.
Then we have Acts, purportedly written by Mark which is just a
documentary of events. After that until Revelation, we have the
“epistles” which are personal letters from the apostles to churches with
their advice, admonitions, and sometimes personal opinions and specific
instructions or advice to individuals and groups. I can’t imagine that
when they wrote these letters to their congregations that they
envisioned this “Christianity” that has evolved placing their
correspondence on the same level as the prophets of old, and calling it
“the word of God”
Then finally comes “The Revelation of Jesus Christ” purported to be
dictated to and written down by the beloved apostle John. If we can
believe that this is genuine it would be the only part of the “new
testament” that qualified as “scripture” as it would be the only part
that was received in the manner that we are told the prophets of old
did. i.e. a direct dictation session from God, which is the premise that
we are asked to accept from the old testament scriptures. Ok, sorry
going tangent.
3.I/we learned in wwcg the Biblically correct teaching that Christ
hid the truth from the masses. (“why do you speak to them in
parables”….”because to you it is given to know the secrets of the KOG
but to them it is not given…) so we knew that according to what we
believed that evangelism was not Christ’s agenda. There is no need to
convince or convert anyone as God’s “church” is just a group chosen to
serve mankind in the age to come. So, no pressure I reason. It makes no
difference what anyone believes and there is no reason for a church that
recruits members and solicits money from them for what?
My conclusions include that all of Christianity is false BS and that
God if he exists has no religion and that religion is the curse of the
earth and that one possible explanation for our existence is the plan
outlined in the Scriptures. It would be the obvious conclusion that I
choose that belief because I was taught it as a child. I have rejected
much of what I was taught as a child. I think that the reason I hold to
this choice of beliefs is because it makes sense that God is creating a
family and that the only way he could do it was by allowing, or actually
causing, us to experience the consequences of living in a selfish,
non-loving world and seeing the horror of living outside of God’s law of
love.
I know it’s sophomoric but as Christ pointed out the whole law can be
summed up in two commands, love God and love your brother. We don’t
need any commandments if we love. Thanks Beatles. When money and power
come into the picture is when all people, who are basically good, run
a-muck. The love of money and power has consumed so many. (money is
power) HWA loved his power and prestige it seems. You always hear (when
people visit some third world country where the population is dirt poor)
“the people were so sweet and kind and beautiful! I never in my life
met such kind, good people. Yes, because they have no access to the
“root of all evil” (oh no, I just quoted PAUL!
Thanks for your work and patience.
Ron Rubottom