The Missing Dimension: www.missingdimension.com
Home Page Herbert Armstrong Splinters Mailbag
Editorial Links Update Page Site Guide
Flurry's PCG Cult Garner Ted Armstrong Living Church of God United Church of God
Previous Updates
Please note: Links may no longer be current
Archives: November 2001 - January 2002

August - October 2001

January 28 Edition

Hanegraaf again: Hank Hanegraaf has been a longstanding advocate for the Worldwide Church of God under Joe Jr.  The slick radio presenter has attracted some controversy himself, however. The following thumbnail bio comes from Pam Dewey's excellent site.

Hank Hanegraaf: Controversial successor to the late Walter Martin as the head of Martin's Christian Research Institute. Author of a number of books of research on modern religious movements. Member of Chuck Smith's Calvary Chapel. Martin's widow and family have challenged Hanegraaf's claims to have been Martin's hand-picked successor, and disagree with some of his decisions involving the ministry. Credentials as legitimate researcher have been challenged by admission of incidents of plagiarism, and by charges of former CRI employees that he took credit for research done by others.

The second "Bible Answer Man" broadcast featuring Thomas Lapacka aired January 25. Hanegraaf indulged in some major butt-kissing directed at Joe & co. Callers included a couple of current pastors in the WCG.

February WN: It'd be enough to drive old time hard liners to distraction. The February WN features articles recounting how different WCG congregations celebrated Christmas at the end of last year. And there's a photo of President-for-Life Tkach snapped at his surprise 50th birthday celebration. If that's not enough to get the holdouts spluttering, worse is to follow. An article on The End by Michael Morrison confirms that the WCG leadership no longer holds to any type of millennialist view: sorry folks, the World Tomorrow has been cancelled.

Revelation 20 speaks of a 1,000-year reign of Christ and the saints. Some Christians interpret this literally as a 1,000-year kingdom that Christ will set up when he returns. Other Christians view the 1,000-year period figuratively, symbolizing the rule of Christ in the church before his return.

For example, the number 1,000 may be used figuratively (Deut. 7:9; Ps. 50:10), and there is no way to prove that it must be taken literally in Revelation. Revelation is written in a highly figurative style. No other scriptures speak of a temporary kingdom to be set up when Christ returns. Indeed, verses such as Daniel 2:44 suggest that the kingdom will be eternal, without any crisis 1,000 years later.

If there is a millennial kingdom after Christ returns, then the wicked will be resurrected and judged 1,000 years after the righteous are (Rev. 20:5). But Jesus’ parables do not suggest any such interval (Matt. 25:31-46; John 5:28-29). The millennium was not part of Jesus’ gospel. Paul wrote that the righteous and the wicked will be resurrected on the same day (2 Thess. 1:6-10).

Do you agree with Michael? The latest poll asks if there will be a literal 1000 year millennium. The previous poll result is below.

Church of God groups have traditionally discouraged members from political voting or standing for office. Do you:
Agree
Disagree
Have no view
24.66%
71.23%
04.11%
There were 73 responses to this poll

Regarding finances, Controller Kelly comments:

Income for 2001 was more than $29.6 million... Expenses for 2001 were just over $34.5 million. We used $4.8 million from the church reserve fund to meet expenses. That is not good news, but it was within the parameters we set at the beginning of the year.

We will need to continue budgeting funds from reserves until the close of escrow on the Pasadena campus.

Prophecy Scoreboard: Richard Burkard, creator of www.laughline.com, writes:

I posted this tonight at JLF, but thought your readers might be interested in this, too:

It's amazing the things that pass through your mind at a worship service. There I was this Sabbath, hearing my Pastor talk about the unusually warm January weather here in the U.S. South -- and it hit me. What if there was a place where predictions and "prophecies" of ministers could be posted for all to see -- to see if they really come true? This way we wouldn't debate back and forth about what the man said or if he really meant it. It would be there, and we'd find out the (ahem) plain truth.

After the service, it didn't take long to prepare it... You send in the prophecies and predictions of the ministers (PLEASE don't make any up; I don't want lawsuits), and we'll post them on the Big Board. We'll mark who has the prophetic gift (and who doesn't) as things come true -- or false!

This doesn't have to be limited to COG'ers, either. We all know plenty of other prophetic preachers are out there. This is an interactive scoreboard -- so report what you hear, and let's sort the wheat from the chaff together!

You can go direct to the prophecy scoreboard at http://www.laughline.com/prophecy.html. If only someone had come up with this idea years ago. Submissions for the scoreboard can be sent to rburkard@yahoo.com. While on the site why not check out Laughline's report of the Darryl Henson story.

January 26 Edition

Smooching up to the donors:  Joe Tkach has written a thank you epistle to the members who have bankrolled his church in 2001. "It is", says Joe, "a privilege for all of us to work alongside people like you who have dedicated their lives to serving Jesus Christ." Yeah, big privilege. Just don’t expect a vote or a detailed financial statement.

smooch.jpg (14197 bytes)Joey goes on to list the accomplishments of the last 12 months

In the United States this year, more than 490 people were baptized, 9 new churches were started and 24 elders were ordained. Although we do not yet have final year-end international figures, we are delighted to report that around the world there were more than 750 baptisms, over 35 new congregations and 25 ordinations. The rate of baptisms is increasing. For instance, in Northern Luzon, Philippines, 94 people have been baptized in the last 8 weeks. Twenty-five new brethren were baptized in Togo in November alone, and another 30 in Zambia. I am most excited to report that for the first time we have full-time and part-time missionaries deployed in Asia. These include 4 full-time teams and 5 tentmaker teams. We have 3 teams working in China, 1 in Viet Nam, 1 in Japan, and 1 in Thailand, in addition to 5 teams working in the tribal Muslim areas of the Philippines. A good portion of these deployments were made possible by a grant that came from your generous donations.

You’d almost think business was booming. But even the most naïve WCG member must know that this is very selective reporting indeed. In the footsteps of the church’s glorious founding Apostle, Joey apparently believes in the "mushroom theory" (keep the members in the dark and shovel on the manure.) Contrast Joe’s oily PR with this recent assessment from a serving WCG minister:

I doubt very much whether the denomination will survive more than a few more years, attendance and income cannot keep going down and down and down… Our congregation's affiliation with the WCG is very superficial and most would be happy to cut the umbilical chord.

Lapacka on Hanegraaf:  Thomas Lapacka, the WCG minister who morphed into a Missouri Lutheran reverend, appeared on Hank Hanegraaf's "The Bible Answer Man", January 24. He was scheduled to do a follow-up on the 25th. The broadcast can be heard in real audio format here.

Hanegraaf and Lapacka shovel the praise on the Tkaches liberally. Earl Williams is actually referred to once  - but not by name. Lapacka's book, Out of the Shadows, is given the hard sell. The phrase "from cult to cross" occurs again and again. There are some interesting anecdotes (the "Xmas fern" for example), as long as you can control the gagging reflex each time Hank gushes with glib, one-eyed, self-promoting evangelical chutzpah. Neither man shows any awareness of the severely compromised nature of the present WCG, and its continuing cultic structure.

Buffie takes a bow, Spanky rewrites history: Raymond McNair's by-line has appeared for the first time in the Living Church News. The errant evangelist may now be sufficiently "rehabilitated" after bolting from the leadership of the sinking CGCF to throw himself on Rod Meredith's tender mercies.

As for Meredith, his lead article in the same issue is almost surreal.

In the early days, most brethren called Mr. Armstrong "Brother Armstrong," or they would address Mr. and Mrs. Armstrong as "Herbert and Loma." A closeness and friendship prevailed that partly faded out later on. As the Work grew, a sense of adulation crept into people's attitude toward Mr. Armstrong...

Also, the "setting of dates" began to creep in. Mr. Armstrong and a few of the older ministers began to set specific dates for the end of the Work, for Christ's coming and for a series of punishments to begin on our nations. Of course, that was unwise...

... many of us in the Church began to think of ourselves too much as God's "pet" people, took liberties we should not have done in setting dates, and looked down in a wrong way on "worldly" people...

The natural tendency is for people to follow a man whom they can see - not Christ... I do not want you "following Rod Meredith" or "following Herbert Armstrong" or following any man as such. You can and should follow us as we follow Christ...

... Mr. Armstrong was human - and at times did entertain praise and encouragement too much... (Are You an Armstrongite? Living Church News, January/February 2002)

At first blush you might imagine that Spanky had made a long overdue breakthrough here. Missing, however, is any personal admission that he himself set dates, adulated Herb or looked down on others "in a wrong way". And, wouldn't you know it, in another article in the same issue he makes the usual call for the flock to accept "reproof and correction" from God's "true ministers and servants" (i.e. obey or else!)

A Generation Is Passing: Brian Knowles' latest column is something of a tribute to two individuals who have recently passed from the Church of God scene, Bill McDowell and Ernest Martin. Knowles (a former Plain Truth editor) writes:

When the Lord takes into account the lives of Ernest and Bill, I hope he will consider the ways in which they have blessed others. Ernest had the courage to tell the truth about tithing, the identity of "Israel," and other subjects while others cringed from doing so. Though I did not agree with all of his theology, I do believe he was sincere in his motives. He genuinely sought understanding. He was willing to be a maverick, a loner and a pioneer. He loved history and he mined it for all the nuggets he could extract. He was passionate about his studies. Only time will tell whether he was right about the "Star of Bethlehem," or the location of the 2nd Temple. At least he was willing to explore. He sought to be an original thinker and to break new ground. He was willing to think outside of the box. I admire such people.

Ernest Martin was to be buried at the Willamette National Cemetery in Portland, Oregon on Friday, January 25.

Beware slobs and women in pants! One useful source of information on splinter groups is "the Plain Truth web site". The material there is current and reasonably comprehensive, particularly on the LCG and PCG. The anonymous web master seems sympathetic to the UCG, but has some definite opinions of his own.

Considering what goes on in some of the other Worldwide Church of God (WCG) splinter groups, the United Church of God (UCG) is probably still the best WCG splinter group around. It is not only the largest, but also the most open and honest of the "big three" splinter groups… Hopefully, the freedom in the UCG won't be misused and abused by too many people and just lead to a church full of guys who dress like slobs, and women who wear pants to church and have men's haircuts.

January 23 Edition

Play it again Herb: Here's a special treat for music lovers. By clicking on the link you can hear a recording of Maestro Herb tinkling the ivories with an arrangement of Fibich’s Poeme. The names of the supporting accompanists are not known. The WCG founder was proud of his musical talent and taste, part of the inspiration for the concerts once held in the Auditorium. The Apostle’s interpretation, however, seems a tad on the slow side at over 3 minutes. You’ll need the free Real Player program. Savoring the music along with a glass of Harveys Bristol Cream - another of Herb's passions - would be appropriate too!

An "idiot's guide" to second tithe: One of the abiding joys of belonging to an Armstrong Church of God sect is the privilege of tithing at least twice!  The January issue of United News includes an article by Tony Wasilkoff which explains - as one would to a very small child (or a congenital moron) - what a very good idea this is. Wasilkoff calls second tithe "God's savings plan."  He also reminds the fortunate constituency of UCG about "tithe of the tithe", where you turn in ten percent of the saved second tithe directly to UCG (which is seemingly accredited by God to receive cash and checks in His name)

Through the years we have heard of inspiring accounts of people in dire circumstances who found ways to save up for the Feast of Tabernacles. They collected pop bottles, picked berries, delivered newspapers and did various odd jobs... When the Feast arrived, these individuals had (with God's blessing) been able to save up a significant amount! ... God's ways are superior and they really do work. How wonderful are the Holy Days and how wonderful is the financial plan to observe them! (The Better Travel Plan, United News, Jan. 2002)

Yup, wonderful!  Poverty is such a character-developing condition!  Here at The Missing Dimension we were so inspired by Tony's article that we've decided to save up all our pop bottles for Tony to collect next time he's in the neighborhood.

Auditorium Blues: The following item comes from the Pasadena Star News. The story, City Council weighs scenarios of taking auditorium as 'gift', is written by staff writer Elizabeth Lee.

PASADENA -- The City Council met behind closed doors Monday morning to discuss its concerns about acquiring the Ambassador Auditorium, the lavishly appointed performance hall on the former Ambassador College campus.

Legacy Partners, which wants to develop the west Pasadena campus into a massive housing community, has proposed handing over the auditorium to the city if its development plans win council approval. The transfer is touted as a "gift" to the city, but one council member said he's worried such a gift could end up costing the city handsomely.

"A huge concern is, who maintains this thing if it can't support itself?" City Councilman Steve Haderlein said. "I, for one, am very concerned about it because I don't want the city to be obligated to pay for the maintenance of a shuttered Ambassador Auditorium."

The council gave no new directions to city staff at Monday's meeting, Mayor Bill Bogaard said; but Haderlein said the council decided to have an informal "subcommittee" of its members talk with the developer and the Worldwide Church of God, present owners of the property, about its concerns. The council began this discussion in closed session Jan. 14, but ran out of time before it could finish and called a special meeting for Monday, a council holiday.

The 1974 auditorium -- one of the most acoustically superior facilities in the United States -- is owned by the church, which has entered into escrow to sell the auditorium and the rest of the campus to Legacy.

Legacy, which doesn't want to be burdened with operating the auditorium, wants to buy the facility using tax-exempt bonds, which would be repaid by future homeowners in the development. Such a financing mechanism is called a Community Facilities District, or Mello-Roos District. The developer would then deed the auditorium to the city, which would lease it for free to a nonprofit foundation for operation. But observers question whether a nonprofit agency can keep the auditorium afloat.

"The reality is, this 'gift' has many financial strings attached," said Vince Farhat, president of the nearby West Pasadena Residents Association. He said he wants to know, "Who's going to be left holding the bag if the auditorium fails?"

Legacy Vice President Bill Shubin said there will be two fallback plans if the Ambassador foundation can't raise enough money to keep the auditorium going. Virtually everyone agrees the auditorium will need private fund-raising to stay in the black, because ticket sales won't cover operating costs.

A "cultural services corporation" funded by a resale fee on Legacy project homes will pay for shuttering the auditorium if that becomes necessary, Shubin said. If that corporation can't foot the bill, then the responsibility goes to the project's homeowner associations, he said. "The city would be protected from those costs," Shubin said.

But others aren't so sure. Haderlein said council members considered the scenario of project residents at some future date "marching" on City Hall because they were paying the costs both to purchase the facility and keep it mothballed.

The council has also discussed the auditorium's value, Haderlein said. A real estate appraisal has pegged the auditorium at about $22.5 million, but different types of appraisals yield lower figures. The council has also been discussing the possibility the city would help fund the construction of a parking garage next to the auditorium. But Councilman Paul Little said he wouldn't support such an expenditure. "Iwant to make sure the city's not going to be on the hook for any financial obligations down the road," he said. "I'm not wanting to obligate the city in any way, either to operate it ... or build any infrastructure to support it. We have a lot more pressing needs in the city of Pasadena."

Shubin said the auditorium, contrary to what some critics claim, really is a gift from the church and Legacy. Imposing the Community Facilities District tax on future residents drives down the sale value of the homes, he said. That lowers Legacy's return on the development, and therefore lowers the sale price it's willing to pay the church for the campus property.

If the council rejects the Mello-Roos financing district, it could derail the entire development, Shubin said. "I think that jeopardizes the entire transaction. We do not really have another method of financing the acquisition of the auditorium."

January 21 Edition

Flurry's Last Hour:  The members of the PCG have been blessed with wonderful new truth over recent months. Gerry has been pulling the prophetic bunnies out of the hat in quick order.  To start with he has tightened the mantle around his own shoulders with the release of Who Is That Prophet? - a booklet "proving" that you-know-who is in fact you-know-what, and hence a very big punkahwallah indeed in the great scheme of things. Trifle with Gerry and the Lake of Fire awaits!  But wait, there's more!  Yes folks, we've been living in the prophesied "Last Hour" since May last year.  Here's what the latest Philadelphia Trumpet has to say:

...our editor in chief brought out the following in his Personal in the November 2001 edition of this magazine:

"In a sermon in May, I said we should expect this last hour to be different than any other hour in the history of man! Just four months later, the face of the world changed dramatically. ... THE WORLD HAS ENTERED ITS LAST HOUR! IT IS PLAIN FOR ALL TO SEE!"

They are powerful words. They are revelatory words, straight out of your Bible! As Gerald Flurry showed in that Personal, the Apostle John, under divine inspiration, wrote the following declarative statement as a message to God's end-time Church: "Children, it is the last hour .... [W]e know that it is the last hour" (I John 2:18; RSV)...

Our founder, Herbert W. Armstrong, had a sharp eye for spotting major world events and connecting them with the thread of biblical prophecy, which declares their outcome far in advance. Our editor in chief continues in the same vision. This magazine attests to that.

Look back over the past year, most especially since May 5, the time of that bold and revelatory declaration by Gerald Flurry that this world, in the present configuration of man's civilization, had entered its last hour...

Our long-time readers realize that the past 12 years have witnessed a powerful outpouring of revelation of biblical, end-time prophecies to the Church that sponsors this magazine...

That is power - real power. The power to predict the future... It's the power that gives driving force to a small army of yielded servants of God to do a work that is destined to shake the world with the most powerful warning of the impending punishment of God! ...

It is undeniably "the last hour"!

The End has begun: dig deep brethren!goose.gif (20718 bytes)

LCG Conference:  According to Carl McNair: "The general conference of Living Church of God ministry from around the world will begin two weeks from next Monday. Mr. Meredith has asked the members of the Council of Elders to arrive in time for a Council of Elders meeting two weeks from today (Friday)."

A General Conference restricted to "ministry" is hardly a general conference. Perhaps LCG uses the term in the sense of a military rank, with Rod assembling the officer corps who then all goosestep in unison?

Place of Safety Poll:  Over 80 votes were received in the Place of Safety poll. The results are below. The new poll asks about voting. Should a member of the church cast a ballot in an election, or stand for public office?

The Place of Safety is best understood as...
Petra
Christ
Somewhere yet to be revealed
Possibly multiple locations
A false doctrine best forgotten
10.98%
25.61%
18.29%
06.10%
39.02%
There were 82 responses to this poll

Sounding Off:  A new page has been added to the site listing Internet message boards and forums with a WCG focus. 

January 18 Edition

Ernest L. Martin:  With sadness we read the following email today:

Dr. Ernest L. Martin, Biblical scholar and personal friend, died this morning at his home in Portland, OR.  I just got off the telephone with his wife Ramona.  He had suffered a heart attack on January 4th, came home thereafter, and seemed to be doing well.  We all had hopes for his recovery, but this morning he suffered a second massive seizure.  He was working at his computer when he died.  His death is a great loss.  His bio would fill many pages, but Ernest would not want anyone to praise him for his accomplishments, in life or in death.  He always felt that his research, and anything he could contribute, was all through the gifts and inspiration of God.  I don't know of any human being I have ever met who believed more firmly in the absolute Grace and Providence of God.

Ernest was a pioneering researcher in the area of Biblical studies, and often his discoveries and conclusions were starkly different from the mainstream.  The three that touched most in my own field of New Testament and Christian Origins were his work on the Star of Bethlehem (now accepted by most planetariums in the world, and also featured as the best solution to the "Christmas story" in Jack Finegan's definitive Handbook of Biblical Chronology), his research on the site of Golgotha being the Mt. of Olives, and his most startling conclusion--that BOTH of the Jewish Temples were located south of the so-called Temple Mount and Western Wall, in the city of David over the Gihon Springs.  I suppose if Ernest turns out to be right on that one it will be the most startling revision in the history of biblical archaeology (not to mention the political repercussions).

Ernest and I disagreed on many theological topics, in fact he often joked with me that he was "Paul" and I was "James," in the current spectrum of things, but that there was room for both of us in the quest for the historical Jesus and the significance of his teachings through the ages.  Ernest was THE fundamental inspiration for the greatest project I have ever undertaken, the Original Bible Project, over which I have labored now for nearly a decade. 

I will sadly and sincerely miss Ernest L. Martin.  I saw him in Denver, CO in November and we had a long and very warm conversation together at the annual meeting of the AAR/SBL.  He was in fine form, quintessential Ernest L. Martin, as I will always remember him.

His Web site, www.askelm.com is active and contains information on most of his research, and will soon post updates about his death and events to follow.

My heart and prayers are with his family, especially his dear son Samuel, one of my best friends, who was recently married, and now lives in Jerusalem.

Sadly,
James D. Tabor

Ernest Martin, a professor of theology at Ambassador College, was an influential figure, both during and especially after his time in the WCG.  His advocacy of a version of New Covenant teaching predated the current leadership's by decades.  Many readers will remember the huge impact his writings and tapes had.  We join in offering our condolences to the family.

Sunny Utah Beckons: The latest issue of The Journal carries a major story on the Darryl Henson’s Congregation of God and their belief that Utah is the Place of Safety – a story The Missing Dimension first broke on January 5. The following quote appears on Bob Thiel’s site:

Mr. Henson said he is not sure Utah is the place of safety, yet he made several comments that indicate he thinks it's a pretty safe bet. Some of this thinking has to do with the many places in Utah with biblical names. Another indication is the topography of the state. In his dream "two maps appeared," he reiterated, "and I asked myself where did this come from. I saw the Idaho border and the Sea of Galilee. There was Moab and Amman. I got the atlas out, and in the southeast corner of Utah was Moab." Mr. Henson also places significance on Zion. His congregation has sponsored a Feast site at Zion National Park in Utah for the past two years. Mr. Henson explained that this area meets the requirements for the place of safety...Mr. Henson sees relevance in Joshua 15, where Joshua assigns the tribe of Judah its boundaries. This passage talks about a "salt sea" (verse 2), which could bring to mind Utah's Great Salt Lake. "If you take away the J [from the word Judah] and change the D to a T, you have Utah," he pointed out. Also, in verse 55 appears the name Juttah, which is the same as Utah if one simply deletes the J and one of the T's.

Woo-hoo!  Whoever said cultists didn’t know didley squat about scholarship. "Pack your bags Myrtle, we’re heading to Mormon country!"

Perhaps Mr. Henson is unaware that the US military has major strategic bases out there in his Place of Safety, making Utah a prime target for any first strike by the coming "Beast Power" (another Herb doctrine that we’re sure Henson has heard of.)  Then again, who are we to argue with Darryl's dreams?

Out of Africa: UCG President Les McCullough is off to Ghana to formally bring the ministers of the Remnant Church of God into the fold.  In his January 15 letter he mentions the UCG's British operations as well:

The World Tomorrow radio broadcast from the Isle of Man in the British Isles is doing a good job. John Jewell, a member of the Council of Elders and CEO of the work in the British Isles, gave us a report on the program and on some of the advertising efforts that have been undertaken there. They are seriously handicapped by the lack of manpower... They now have seven congregations in the British Isles and no employed ministry. That is obviously a difficulty. That isn't to say there are no elders—there are. But, John Jewell is retired and devoting his time to carrying a major part of the workload. Gerhard Marx and others are also giving their time on the Sabbath as well as visiting occasionally.

Herb - A Man of Our Time: Staying with the British theme, Bob Devine, pastor of the UK Global Church of God, a group which survived the ructions that created the LCG, has recently written these words of exhortation to his flock concerning Herb:

We must seriously heed the words of, undisputedly, the greatest man of God in our time.

Uh, Bob, there are a few hands raised over here in the cheap seats who might dispute the "undisputedly" part. And as Herb was born in 1892, and has spent the last 16 long years pushing up daisies in the Pasadena Lawn Cemetery, it's hardly "in our time" any longer.  And it seems that Brian Orchard, writing in the January Church of God News (published by the Hulme sect), agrees.  He writes: "Mr. Armstrong's time has come and gone."  Perceptive chap.

January 16 Edition: 16 years today since Herb's death

Big Bad Bernie: From Dateline Pasadena"Legacy is running into some VERY stiff objections from the community here in Pasadena regarding the number of condo's and buildings they plan on constructing on the Pasadena property.  Threats of lawsuits are swirling about here in town.  They have a meeting with the City Council this coming week to allow the citizens to voice their opinion.

"Bernie our wanna-be Attorney/Real Estate Agent is getting fed up with people objecting to the sale of the property.  So Uncle Bernie has announced that he is going to hold a public meeting in the Ambassador Auditorium sometime in the coming month or so to tell the public HOW IT IS GOING TO BE!

"He is going to tell them that they had better stop delaying the sale of the property, OR he is going to find the quickest buyer he can, and let them tear down every single building, garden and stream on the campus.  If the citizens think they have [reason to] complain now, just wait!"

Willing to change?  The following quote comes from Kevin Armstrong, Associate Pastor of the Toronto West WCG.

New beginnings are exciting. Some time ago, I had a chat with Lon Allison, director of the Billy Graham Center at Wheaton College. He had just returned from a WCG regional conference in the U.S. and was excited about our situation as a church. He remarked that he had never heard of a church organization that was so willing to change itself in order to accomplish its mission. An unspoken purpose in every organization is self-preservation. It is truly remarkable when a group will risk that to accomplish its mission. (January issue of Northern Light)

Doctrinal changes in the WCG are a dime a dozen, imposed from on high and railroaded through, for better or worse. We wonder, though, if Kevin has considered structural change. Did he tell Allison about the continued cultic leadership by one man - and an un-elected, un-mandated one at that? Did he confess to the lack of representative structures? Did he mention the absence of any form of genuine member input in the governance of the sect? Did he honestly address the issue of decision making without consultation with stakeholders (members)? Somehow we find it hard to believe that things are that different North of the border.  In fact, we've never heard of a church organization that's so unwilling to change itself when issues like these are raised. And while cult leaders in Pasadena might be prepared to see the church go to the wall (some might even cheer!), we're pretty sure they've given long, careful consideration to their own personal self preservation. 

Somebody should bring Lon up to speed. 

What's the Beef?  As we reported on December 27, a new forum called Children of Worldwide (COW) was recently launched.  Initially the moderator, amazingmike, assured those posting that there would be no "censorship" of messages. However deletions appeared shortly after. The list has now moved to a new site, and has more than 60 registered users. 

Perhaps inspired by the spirit of Bart Simpson ("Don't have a cow, man!") a new list has now appeared.  This one is called, and we kid thee not, MOO COW (Members Opting Out of Children of Worldwide).  This list has been created by Ron Brendel, and those who miss the Real Christian Forum, and later the Christian Deists Forum, should feel quite at home. To quote Stinger, one of those who's made the move (or should that be moo-ve?), "I think it's going to be a hoot!"

Addendum (Jan. 23): Shortly after posting this Ron moved MOO COW to a new host and restarted the board stating: "I am completely serious about letting people have their say. This will be open, public debate."  Since then the MC list seems to have disappeared. 

January 13

More on Lapacka book: Steve Dalton has written a critique of Tom Lapacka's book Out of the Shadows, one of the first substantial reviews we've seen.  Lapacka's credibility is cast in doubt on a number of issues, particularly his whitewashing of the events of 1974 and the later receivership crisis.  

Lapacka, by not telling the entire story, is using the fallacy of neglected aspect, emphasizing material that confirms his position, but neglecting or denying material that militates against it. He did this in discussing 1974, and he does this throughout the book... why doesn't Lapacka mention [David] Covington in his book? Isn't he an important player in the story? Well, yes, but he's a "dissident." If you're one of those, you're either publicly roasted, or ignored by the WCG and friends. Although the WCG chose to attack him, Lapacka ignores him... He's trying to make a case by emphasizing the facts that support his case, while ignoring the ones that shoot it down.

Dalton also points out that Joe Jr. "graciously" gave parts of the book the royal once-over prior to publishing.  We're surprised he didn't issue an official episcopal imprimatur!

Essential Herb: Who is Stephen W. Boston, and where oh where did he get his PhD in Comparative Religion? And why did he take more than 250 pages to write a hagiography entitled The Essential Teachings of Herbert W. Armstrong?

Yes folks, there's a newly rehashed version of Armstrongism on the market. And, oh my, what a subtitle! "His teachings focused on the Incredible Human Potential. Did he solve the Mystery of the Ages?"

The short answer is, of course, "you MUST be kidding!"  The mysterious "Dr. Boston" however sees things differently. For $20.95 you can share his naiveté. The release date (January 16) coincides with the 16th anniversary of Herb's kicking the bucket in 1986: so naturally we're all choked up!  This singular tome has been published through iUniverse, a print-on-demand company. The entire thing can be previewed online.  We suggest you have a stiff drink first.

Special Notice: WCG Talk: Next Saturday night [US], there will be a text and audio chat available for those who'd like to discuss "the Worldwide Church of God and its derivative groups in a free and frank manner."  To participate you'll first need to download the free Paltalk program from www.paltalk.com.  The group will be listed under the "religion" category as WCG Talk.  Times are as below. 

US Pacific: 8PM Saturday 19 US Eastern: 11PM Saturday 19 US Mountain: 9PM Saturday 19
Sydney, Australia: 3PM Sunday 20 Auckland, NZ: 5PM Sunday 20 GMT: 4AM Sunday 20

If your time zone isn't listed, a quick calculation can be made using timezoneconverter.com

January 10

Lapacka Interview: A recent short interview with former WCG minister Tom Lapacka can be heard online in Real Audio format. It was broadcast January 8 on KFUA, a radio station owned by the Lutheran Church - Missouri Synod.  Lapacka, now a pastor and administrator in the LCMS, delivers few surprises in what seems to be a promotion for his book Out of the Shadows, published by LCMS-owned Concordia Publishing House, and which we first mentioned back on December 5.  We doubt, however, whether this effort will sell many copies.

In Rod We Trust:  Appearing recently on a discussion board was this charming tale of life at AC, and an insight into the compassionate nature of the man who is now "presiding evangelist" of his own designer-cult.:

On other occasions the assembly and forum served as a vehicle to brow beat and scream at the student body en masse.  Probably the worst for this was Rod Meredith who would bellow and shriek into the microphone in an barely controlled rage...  I remember one of the last assemblies of the school year, in May, and a lot of the kids had plans to go home for the summer.  Problem was that the students supplied a lions share of the labor to keep the work going, in the mail room, press building, and other jobs.  This is not to say that there were no other full time employees because there certainly were (and I felt sorry for those people).  Anyway, in this final assembly, Meredith was at the podium doing his usual shriek and bellow act, this time about the kids going home for the summer.  I remember to this day him saying that the boys just wanted to go home to "DAYDREAM AND MASTURBATE" (when they could be at school working).  I mean literally screaming into the microphone. You had to be there to know what I am saying.  A lot of these students were kids who had been away from home for the first time in their lives and were homesick and missed their families and parents.

Even more than 30 years after this incident I still get angry thinking about this uncalled for and abusive diatribe...

Creationism Rulz OK? Just in case anyone was under the illusion that most MD readers were trendy liberal types who eschewed a literal approach to the Bible, along comes the poll result on human evolution.  Those who believe it's not possible to accept evolution while being a genuine Christian outnumber their progressive brethren by a margin of almost 3:1. 

Can someone accept the idea of human evolution and still be a Christian in a meaningful sense?
Yes
Maybe
No 
23.19%
10.14%
66.67%
There were 69 responses to this poll

The new poll asks, what is your understanding of the Place of Safety?  Is it Petra, Christ, an unknown location, multiple locations, or just another nutty bit of Armstrongism?

Alternative URL: Life is hard enough without difficult-to-remember web addresses. To make life easier  www.missingdimension.com was registered last year. Unfortunately this only links to the home page, while the Update page receives by far the most hits.  Many returning visitors bookmark it, but that can be a problem when you're logging in away from home. If so, you may want to try www.wcgupdate.cjb.net

January 8

Greetings from the Festival Office: Douglas Becker's site is worth checking out - but it's not for the humor-impaired. There's a Festival Office missive, a news report on drive-by shootings involving the Imperial Youth Symphony Orchestra, a salute to Premise Keepers and a story about cat exorcism.  On a more sober note, Doug (author of Assertive Incompetence) has re-published a series by Ron Brendel on the Apostleship of Herb that originally appeared on the now defunct Real Christian Forum, and a Herbivorous feature of his own.  

Pasadena Pabulum: Out in Pasadena, the happy-clappy WCG congregation led by Dennis Pelley has listed seven goals for the benighted brethren in 2002. They are:

1. To come to know Jesus on a more intimate level as best Friend.
2. To yield to Jesus as Lord, asking him to change me 
3. To develop the same "heart for lost people" that Jesus has.
4. To become a faithful and effective disciple of Jesus 
5. To become equipped to bring others to Jesus and disciple them 
6. To reach out and help meet some of the needs in our community
7. To give more of my time, talent and treasure to my Lord

Sounds of gagging have been heard throughout the Greater Los Angeles area.

Project Linus: Many Christian denominations have associated charitable arms. Lutheran World Service and Caritas spring to mind. The closest WCG ever got was probably the AICF, though the largest slab of its budget seems to have been directed to PR, the Auditorium and concerts, with an occasional token project overseas to ease the way for Herb to visit on the testimonial dinner circuit.  The UCG seems to have forged a strong connection with Lifenets, a charity established by UCG minister Vic Kubik. Recently Project Linus, based on an initiative by members in Kubik's Terre Haute, Indiana congregation, has seen blankets for Afghani babies delivered to refugee camps.

January 5

Off to the Place of Safety: Forget Petra. The Place of Safety is in Utah. At least according to A Congregation of God, a group pastored by Darryl Henson. Recently we received the following email:

My mother-in-law recently left her husband and moved to Kenab, [Kanab?] Utah.  Her church believes it is time to "flee" and apparently this is their "place of safety"...  Do you know anything about this group?  I am really worried about her and the future of this group. 

Thanks to some digging by Richard Burkard, the group, which the correspondent suspected might be Fred Coulter's Christian Biblical Church of God, has been identified as A Congregation of God. The information was given to Richard by the CBCG, anxious to distance itself from the Henson sect. The Congregation of God web site provides the following information.

Our pastor, Darryl Henson, is a 1966 graduate of Ambassador College in Pasadena, ordained by Mr. Armstrong, and was a pastor of churches in that organization thereafter. His parents came into the then Radio Church of God in the early fifties when he was a child. He was out of the ministry for about ten years after having a marriage annulment by Herbert Armstrong. He went to Alaska for about 14 years and earned his own living until 1996 when hired by Church of the Great God in January 1996. From there, he went independent in August 2000 due to concerns over the calculated Hebrew calendar.

Kanab is the site of a number of famous Western movie shoots, including The Lone Ranger. Which somehow seems appropriate in light of the discovery of yet another stand-alone Armstrong sect. Hi Ho Silver! Away!

January 3

Joe's gotta go: MD readers sent Joe Tkach an overwhelming vote of no confidence in the latest poll result. Time, Mr. Pastor General, to come out from behind the protective skirts of a shonky self-serving "episcopal" structure and do the right thing.

In the circumstances Joe Tkach is doing a good job as Pastor General. Do you:

Strongly agree
Agree
Feel undecided 
Disagree
Strongly disagree

04.23%
05.63%
05.63%
14.08%
70.42%

There were 71 responses to this poll

Genesis, Darwin and all that: Can a person accept the idea of human evolution and be a faithful Christian? Take the latest poll.

Stats: The Missing Dimension closed the year with 103 978 page views, with visitors coming from 71 countries. December was another record month, with 19 825 hits. 

December 30

2001 in Review: A quick peek back at the archives - a year in the ongoing soap opera of Armstrongism.

January – April: Joey nailed his "true colors" to the mast with an editorial on leadership in the February WN. In essence it seemed to say "I’m the boss, so go away and don’t bother me!" … The WN continued its unstated policy of only publishing the most ingratiatingly obsequious letters to the editor, making for a very short letters column … Flurry was forced to withdraw the PCG offer of copies of such Herb classics as Mystery of the Ages and The Incredible Human Potential following a court ruling in WCG’s favor … Aussie WCG franchise manager Rod Matthews, using words he probably later regretted, described the regional magazine Living Today as "vital" as a "community outreach tool for congregations" … WCG income in the first quarter was down 12%

May: This web site was re-launched as The Missing Dimension … Zondervan’s publicity for a forthcoming book by Mike Feazell included a burning picture of Herb on the cover, provoking outrage among some ...

June: Living Today, vital a few months before, becomes totally disposable, and WCG Australia dumps it … Spanky Meredith’s financial manager, Fred Dattolo, jumps ship, joining Flurry’s PCG cult …

July: Meredith calls a Bastille Day fast for his Living Church of GodThe Church of God: A Christian Fellowship crumbles as a clutch of ministers defect rather than cuddle up to the United Church of God.  A new cult, The Church of the Eternal God, is formed …

August: The WCG’s "Summerfest" fell flat on its face with low attendance despite the usual gushing PR … Self-styled "episcopal" leader Joe Jr. wrote a begging letter to the membership urging them to "continue to give generously", then axed several jobs at Pasadena HQ …

September: Within hours of the terrible events of 9/11 Roderick C. Meredith was milking the tragedy for all it was worth. God was punishing the US for its evil ways and worse would follow. He later "clarified" his comments in a carbon copy of the back-pedaling by Falwell and Robertson … Pope Joe had a hissy-fit and accused the Missing Dimension of "spiritual terrorism" … The WN failed to publish the church’s audited accounts in full …

October: The LCG and UCG reported increased attendance at their Feast sites … Spanky caterwauled for more monetary support from LCG members …

November: Nine hopefuls lined up in the race to be president of the UCG … Legacy put on a concert in the Ambassador Auditorium in a bid to gather more public support … Meredith belatedly denied John Tuit’s statements in a 1981 book, and then was hit with new allegations as Suzanne and Wiley Black’s notarized statements were published on the Web. In these Suzanne Black recollected a conversation where Spanky tried to solicit her services, pimp style, for HWA …

December: David Hulme poked his head up from the edge of obscurity to launch a one-off documentary style program on the Discovery Channel

It's been a rare year, and 2002 promises more of the same.

The view from Cincinnati: In a December 27 member letter UCG President Les McCullough mentions that the enrollment this year at Ambassador Bible Center now stands at 55, 15 higher than last year. The sect's flagship magazine, Good News, has a January print run of 472,028. And needless to say, it wouldn't be an Armstrong derivative church if there wasn't prominent mention of the all important moolah.

We have been encouraged to see the income of the Church continue on its steady pace, especially after a dip we experienced for the two weeks directly following Thanksgiving. It has been strong since then and now the most critical variable that we follow, Category One Income adjusted for extraordinary items, is running at about 9 percent above the corresponding period last fiscal year. That is about 3 percent above what we had budgeted.

Hey Les, any chance of passing on some tips to Joey?

Gimme that Ole Time Armstrongism: The Caretaker at herbertwarmstrong.com has preserved one of Herb's inspiring 1962 articles especially for all you ladies. Yes, God's Apostle makes a definitive ruling on women's dress. At last, the truth made plain!  A sample passage (emphasis in the original):

Candidly, when I see a female with a skirt tight enough to call attention to the shape of her hips, especially when tight below the hips and under the buttocks, I know that she is either careless and needs sharp admonishing or else she is wearing it deliberately to attract male eyes and arouse lust toward her in men's minds.

Do you want to know my personal reaction when I see such an example? It makes me feel that such a girl or woman needs either a good lecture driven home by a sound SPANKING of what she so brazenly displays, or to be classed as a fallen woman and a common prostitute.

THIS IS PLAIN LANGUAGE!  I mean it to be plain, and I want the women in God's Church to know it is coming from God's Minister, who speaks by Christ's authority!

Yes, Herb's, um, fingers itched when he saw the brazen female form. 

When many of you women wear skirts as high as the knee, and which completely expose the knees when sitting, your skirts are an abomination in GOD'S eyes. I wonder, frankly, if God doesn't blush when HE sees you!  Are you women who do this, deliberately trying to tempt men into breaking the spirit of God's law against adultery?  Are you trying to make yourselves adultresses [Herb's spelling]?  Are you not breaking the very spirit of that law, yourselves?

Does this man have a problem or what? And Christ's Apostle continues:

In our instruction to parents in proper child rearing we teach that when you spank your child, it must be sufficiently severe to impress the lesson - painful enough that he will not want to cause it to be repeated very soon. In this instruction to the spiritual children in God's church, your Pastor is making this correction to those who need it, I sincerely hope, plain enough and painful enough that it shall not need repeating!

Hey, weren't the Sixties great!  The link above is to a PDF document and requires Acrobat Reader.

Shrunken pomegranates? On the lighter side, the iconoclastic British Christian site, Ship of Fools, has its very own Biblical Curse Generator.

Lost for a smart remark to see off your enemies? Unable to deliver that killer insult? Put an end to "I was speechless!" misery with the amazing Biblical Curse Generator, which is pre-loaded with blistering put-downs as delivered by Elijah, Jeremiah and other monumentally angry saints. Simply click the button ... and get ready to smite your foes with a custom-made curse straight out of the Old Testament.

One example: Thou shalt beget difficult teenagers, thou offspring of a squashed cockroach! Ouch! Try one out on your local Armstrong pastor.

December 27

Ocker Shocker: The Australian WCG is going through lean times according to the December issue of the Aussie Worldwide News.

... the second half of the year has seen an overall decline in contributions of about 13 percent.

Elsewhere the publication reveals that there were only 37 baptisms "around the region" during 2001. This presumably includes all of Australia, New Zealand, Asia and the Pacific.  2001 was also the year that the magazine Living Today, the regional equivalent of The Plain Truth, was canned.  Despite this the Aussie editor, perhaps displaying an evil sense of humor, titled one feature article A Year of Achievement, and readers are assured that "congregational life has improved immensely."

Children of WCG: There are a large number of WCG-related message boards on the web. The newest is called Children of the Worldwide Forum

This forum is for members, former members and those brought up in the WCG and all those interested in discussing the past and present teachings of the Worldwide Church of God (WCG) and the many offshoot groups. This is a privately owned forum and is not an official site of the WCG. We do not hide our past; we see the transformation of the church as a great victory for our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. We give glory and honor to him for bringing us out of the shadows and into the glorious light of the gospel.

The board began December 22 and already features a sizeable number of postings. There's even a Xmas poll with wording remarkably similar to the poll we held earlier this month.... 

100K: Yesterday MD chalked up its 100 000th page view since records started back in May, when we logged a meager 1 900 page views. This month we're anticipating more than 19 000.

December 24

PCG wins a round:  According to the latest Journal the Flurry cult has managed a courtroom win against the WCG

The District Court of the Central District of California in Los Angeles on Nov. 5 denied the WCG's move to prevent the Oklahoma-based PCG, founded by Gerald Flurry, from printing and distributing 18 printed works written by Mr. Armstrong.

The ruling does not affect an earlier decision that prevents the PCG from publishing and distributing Mr. Armstrong's book Mystery of the Ages, and the WCG will continue to challenge in the courts the PCG's right to publish the lesser works.

Lesser works?  The rehashed compilation of earlier material that was cobbled together to create Mystery of the Ages - aided by the usual over-the-top PR - probably counts as one of Herb's greatest fizzers.  How much "lesser" can you get?

Controller Ron's Report: Excerpts from the latest WN.

Here are the year-to-date figures: donation income, $19.9 million; other income, $5.5 million. Total for the year so far is $25.5 million. However, expenses for the year are $30.5 million, so we have used more than $5 million from reserves to sustain our budget without making cutbacks in employees, salaried pastors and activities supported by the church.

We continue to experience delays in the sale process, and it now looks like completion of escrow could extend into the middle of 2002. This is a test of our patience—as well as a test of your patience, no doubt but patient we must all be.

The first phase of the transition to a new financial model is to integrate collections into worship services. Our goal for 2001 was to have all congregations do regular collections by the end of the year. I believe most of our churches are now doing so.

A particularly dopey suggestion (ask any budget advisor) follows. 

Donating by credit card has some advantages. First, members can set a monthly amount that remains steady. This helps the church in processing. Also, some credit cards can be attached to affinity programs such as frequent flyer miles, hotel bonus points or even cash back. A word of caution, however: donation by credit card requires strict discipline to pay off the entire balance each month. Maintaining a balance and paying interest on charges would soon offset any benefit.

How many people will read the first part of Kelly's message, think "what a good idea'", and fail to take note of the second part?  

MD seriously advises readers to consider carefully before giving anything to a church that denies its members the basic right of representation through elected structures. No representation means no accountability. If your church is unable to trust you with input into its governance, why should you trust it with your money?

Passover to be Passed Over? According to some reports, the WCG in Pasadena is to drop plans for formal Passover services next year. The story goes that Friendship Baptist Church, which WCG has used as a preaching venue since abandoning the auditorium, is unavailable on that day. Members will be forced to celebrate privately or gather in small groups (or, more likely, just ignore the date completely). It seems incredible to suggest that WCG's administrators can't find an alternate venue. If true it sends another not so subtle signal that the church's ruling oligarchy would like to complete its unilateral transition to evangelical respectability - something it can never do while it insists on retaining its medieval power structures.

Great Scott! Gary Scott's site has been around for a while, but seems to have had a recent makeover. Gary has a major section devoted to the WCG, including his personal reflections as he worked his way through the claims of the PCG, along with essays and links. 

The strangest thing about the Worldwide Church of God is its tendency to be something of an obsession for ex-members. Whether they quit because the WCG administration had abandoned Herbert Armstrong's teachings or they left because the administration had not gone far enough in its sweeping changes, ex-members tend to have put a lot of thought into their WCG experience -- and a lot of it ends up on the worldwide web. Such is the case with my own musings.

We can certainly identify with that

Waiter, waiter: Quite a few caption submissions have been emailed for the photo published on Dec. 21. Any more?

December 21 

Preachin' with Herb: Late Apostle and Elijah redivivus, Herb Armstrong, was a party animal (though not a Xmas party animal!)  In all those tastefully shot photographs that appear on Herb's "fan sites" to this day, showing a dignified Apostle posing for the cameras, we wonder why this portrait doesn't make the lineup.  Shown here is the "Ambassador for World Peace" at one of those deeply moving "testimonial dinners" where he babbled about "a strong hand from someplace", claimed he'd "preached the gospel", then called on the membership to sacrifice as never before.  No wonder he's smiling!

What could the waiter be saying?  "Oh yes, Mr. Armstrong, I call this little pasta number Tangled Web!"?  Email your suggestions for a caption and we'll publish them online.

Joey's Xmas: An original thought on Christmas from current WCG President and Pastor General Joe Junior: "It is actually quite untrue to say that Christmas began as a pagan holiday. It would be the equivalent of saying that baptism began as a pagan ritual because pagans were baptizing initiates before Christians were."  Uh... anyone wanna bite? The PG has also released a January member letter on prayer which seems to take up a large space saying very little. Suggesting Joe knows something about prayer, in the wake of the continuing failure of countless HQ prayers for the speedy sale of the Pasadena campus, seems just a tad presumptuous.

Summer Edition. Okay, so it's Winter in the Northern Hemisphere. But below the equator it's Summer, and here in New Zealand the country is about to close down and head for the beaches. Till mid January we'll be updating the site just twice a week.

December 16  

Dave's Big Day Out: You may need to stock up on popcorn. Today the Discovery Channel airs a major promotion by David Hulme's Church of God - An International Community. British-born Hulme, who describes himself as "an author, minister and Middle East scholar", and once presided over of the UCG, fronts the documentary style program "Cheating God Out of Christianity". Shot on location in Israel it must have cost tithe-payer megabucks to produce, let alone buy the airtime. The show has a web page, and  Real Player video clips can be viewed (Dave will sell you the complete video for $7.95)  "Cheating God Out of Christianity" screens at 8AM, Eastern & Pacific. From the clips we've viewed it seems a professional effort, if a bit naive.

December 15

Jingle Bells?  It seems most MD readers will be going about their business as usual on December 25.  The results of the Xmas poll are below.  We cut off responses at exactly 100 this time, so the percentages correspond to actual votes. This is the highest vote count yet.  Interestingly, the longer the poll stayed online the stronger the vote for preference one.  There'll be a new poll up next week.

How do you intend to mark Xmas this year?

Not at all! It's pagan.
Xmas tree, Santa, the Works!
As a Christian festival without the commercial trappings
As a family occasion without religious significance

42%
21%

20%
17%

There were 100 responses to this poll

Dart on cult culture:  Amongst all the ministerial court jesters and power freaks that the WCG has thrown up over the years, it's sometimes easy to forget that there are a few who broke the mold.  One individual who still commands respect across the trenches is Ronald Dart.  Dart must be one of the most effective speakers the church ever produced, with a rare ability to carry his listeners along with reason and gentle questioning.  In his latest CEM newsletter (released today) he makes some interesting observations. [The publication is available as a PDF document and requires Acrobat Reader to view.]

As everyone knows, the churches in our tradition have suffered terrible trauma in recent years and have had no small difficulty in recovering from it. I can testify from bitter experience that it takes time to work one's way through something like this. And the way we work our way through is by talking it out. But when we have talked and talked and seem no closer to a solution, it may be time to take stock and see what is hindering us from moving on...

We left a corrupt and oppressive culture behind, but we retained more of it than we realize, perhaps more than we can realize unless an observer can point it out to us... I am not speaking of "doctrine" or "truth."  The definition of culture I am using is this: "the sum total of ways of living built up by a group of human beings and transmitted from one generation to another."

... The culture of the Worldwide Church of God was the response of its people to the revelation of God as interpreted by a narrow range of teachers. Much of what these teachers taught was true, but much was not.  And over time, the culture built up around these teachings was simply unendurable by a large number of people and it finally provoked the revolution of 1995...

Exactly where Ron is going with this we're not sure.  But it's refreshing to read something from a former "evangelist" that steps beyond the usual posturing and rant to engage the underlying issues.

December 14

Willie's Five Year Plan: William F. Dankenbring, author of numerous seventies Plain Truth articles and a number of obscure books, has never been wary about setting the prophetic cat among the pigeons. A reader tipped us off to his latest filibuster, a Prophecy Flash article concisely titled The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse Prepare to Ride: The "Times of Jacob's Trouble" - Are They Here, Now?  Willie takes us into the "[off the] deep [end] things of God" in this romp through the Good Book's more lurid passages:

Seven years, subtracted from 4004 B.C., brings us to the year 3997 B.C.  Therefore, this is the date we should count from when computing the length of the sojourn of mankind on this planet under the dominion and influence of Satan the devil.  Thus a simple calculation of subtracting 6000 from 3997 B.C. gives us the date of A.D. 2004!  But if we add 3 years, for the time the Messiah preached the gospel, from 27 to 30 A.D., and exercised authority over Satan during that time (Matt.4:1-4; Luke 4:1-4), this means that the END of man's 6,000 years will most likely be in A.D. 2007. 

Did you all follow that? Yes folks, the burning question is: "Could the year 2001 be the “year of the white horse,” the final hurrah, the final time when American power will be exerted around the world?"  Although Willie doesn't answer the question directly (wise move dude!) it's clear he thinks so. Which leads on to the next step: "Will the year 2002 be the year of the “Red Horse” – leading to war and chaos and troubles in Russia, China, and the Far East?"  And so on it goes. 

Not knowing the “hour” or the “day” is one thing.  But does this mean that we can't know the year?  Most of God's people, down through the centuries, obviously, did not know.  But for those of us in this end-time, can we know?  God has certainly given us many “hints,” as it were, in His Word! ...

Now, if we can know these things, then it is a simple mathematical step to add this number beginning with the time of the placement of the “abomination of desolation,” when we see it, to derive the time of the coming of the Messiah!  It will occur exactly 3 and 1/2 years or 1260 days later!

Although we may not know the exact day or hour, it would appear at least that we will be able to ascertain and know the precise YEAR -- IF we are among those who see the abomination of desolation and perceive it for what it really is!

2007?  Thanks for sharing this significant insight with us Bill.  

UCG Council Ends: Roy Holladay has issued a post-council letter, with his summary of events in Clearwater, Florida. Detailed reports of each day's proceedings are also available online. Two items from Holladay's epistle:

We are very pleased to announce that we officially approved the ordinations and credentials of a record number of 27 ministers, far more than at any previous meeting. Nearly all of these men were elders formerly with the Church of God, a Christian Fellowship, or the Remnant Church of God in Ghana. Both organizations have become part of the United Church of God in the last few months.

We also took another very important step in the months-long process of selecting the next president by devoting an entire day to interviewing the five candidates: Roy Holladay, Clyde Kilough, Dennis Luker, Les McCullough and Richard Pinelli. Each one had a 45-minute presentation, followed by a 45-minute question-and-answer session, to express his views on 28 questions. These questions had been given in advance and covered many aspects of management and leadership. At the next Council meeting in February we will make our selection.

December 12

Tuit & Black Stand Firm: John Tuit, author of the 1981 book The Truth Shall Make you Free, has been brought up to speed with the recent statements by Roderick C. Meredith. Mr. Meredith flatly denied saying anything that Tuit reported (see November 25, Rod Denies Spanking & Porn Claims)  In our inbox today, this message from a WCG researcher:

I talked to John Tuit yesterday. He stands by what he has written about Spanky.

And on the JLF Forum today a correspondent states:

I don't care if Liz says he never spanked her bare bottom as a teenager. I've heard the man say this in sermons myself -- and so what we're left with is that either he did it and now denies it...or he lies from the pulpit.

Also posted today on the JLF Forum, this message from a former student of Wiley Black.

Tonight I had over an hour phone conversation with Wiley Black and it was absolutely a wonderful conversation. I told him about the Expositor story about them being on the web and...  asked him a lot of questions which he freely and willingly answered.

... Wiley informed me they are not angry or upset anymore and had never even thought about doing anything like this at all but Bernard [Kelly] called Wiley and Suzanne for over a year begging them to please tell their story that it needed to be told - they decided after much discussion that yes they would and probably should have done this years ago when things first happened.

They had absolutely NO IDEA that Bernard was going to ask people to send them money - They were MORTIFIED when they read that.  When Suzanne started getting checks in the mail she forwarded them to Wiley to return to the senders.  They wouldn't DREAM of taking money from people and Wiley is writing a letter to all those who sent checks thanking them for their concern about his and Suzanne's welfare and sending them back their checks.  He said they have gotten some wonderful letters from so many people and it has really touched them both to know that so many people care.

When I asked him why they stayed in WCG so long - he said (I'm paraphrasing here) we don't know - but we believed it was the true church and we were NOT supposed to leave it or we would be lost forever.

We talked about many other things that I had been told by former classmates at the Imperial Reunion and he confirmed almost everything I was told and said he could give me names of others who could confirm it too if I wanted it.

Before we ended our conversation Wiley told me to tell people all over the US and wherever the people were they do NOT want your money.

Wiley will be observing his 80th birthday on Dec. 28th...  We spent some time discussing the 60th anniversary of the bombing of Pearl Harbor.  He was there when it was bombed and said the movie "Pearl Harbor" is such a farce.  I know many years ago when I was in school he encouraged us to see the movie "Tora Tora Tora" because he had felt it did a good job on telling the story of the war.  He wishes he now that he had gone to Hawaii for the reunion but he needed to be home...

Hope this helps answer some questions.

For those who had been hoping that Rod's second-hand denials, filtered through Bob Thiel, would be enough to lay these matters to rest, this is hardly good news.

Fire Sale? Why not fire Bernie? Dateline Pasadena. Overheard at a recent Chamber of Commerce function: a member there commented to one of the Pasadena employees that Legacy has a less than glowing respect for Bernie Schnippert’s performance in handling the sale process. Word had it on campus today that they have lowered the price AGAIN for the property. 

December 9

The Missing Dimension in Reconciliation: The WCG has released the latest issue of its newsletter Reconcile, produced by the church’s Office of Reconciliation Ministries. The eight-page document contains some laudable material. An attempt by the UCG to launch a similar ministry recently brought an avalanche of protest from conservative members who saw it as liberal, left wing and potentially in conflict with that church’s arcane belief in British-Israelism. To its shame, UCG seems to have capitulated to the shrieks, howls and gibbering of the extremist section of its constituency.

Among the goals of ORM: "To assist others toward reconciliation with fellow-man in areas where broken relationships exist." The thrust of ORM seems to be in the area of racial reconciliation. However we wonder whether, in the torn and bleeding community WCG stands at the heart of, an equally important focus is on dealing to the shattered relationships among members and former members of the Worldwide Church of God. We wonder what is to prevent the establishment of a working group consisting of both current members, and former members who have credibility and respect in the wider community (people like Wayne Cole spring to mind). Such a group could provide a sounding board and a place where grievances could be heard and hopefully laid to rest, enabling members past and present to move on without rancor or ill will. If the post-Apartheid secular South African government can bring people together to heal the wounds of a tragic history, surely the WCG could do the same through a structure like ORM. 

Unfortunately, despite the best efforts of director Curtis May, it appears that ORM may just be another piece of window dressing designed to parallel similar structures in mainline churches. And the appearance of the obligatory patsy-column by Joseph Tkach (along, of course, with a prominent photograph) indicates that this may all be just another bit of cultic spin.

Spanky-babble II: Those on the Living Church of God co-worker list recently received a stirring letter from Rod Meredith. Here are some excerpts.

For prophetic events are certainly speeding up. Yet very few professing Christians or even ministers or theologians understand the true meaning of these events.

So what is next?

[Yup, Rod knows all this stuff. Lucky for us, huh?]

God may use these diversions [he means America’s current military operations] to greatly weaken us and "break" the pride of our power as prophesied in Leviticus 26:19. Also, Satan may guide circumstances so that these comparatively "little wars" will distract our American and British-descended nations from the really enormous threat posed by the coming European empire!

[Oh yeah, the European empire. Silly us, how could we have forgotten?]

Yet, if we continue in our sinful, hedonistic lifestyles, the eternal God has predicted that He will use a whole series of wars and tragedies to bring upon us the corrective punishment we deserve… we have turned our backs on God.

[Meredith’s God is going to spank us. Not just permit a spanking. None of this namby-pamby stuff for Rod. God is gonna kick butt! Your butt.]

For today, more than ever, there is a "spirit" abroad in our land to turn people away from the true God… That foul "spirit" is the major reason why people are so confused about religion today… The "spirit" to which I am referring is the "spirit of Antichrist"! (I John 4:3).

[Wow, Rod’s just hit the big red "A" button.]

We will show you the real identity and meaning of Antichrist. We will show you what to do about this understanding. And, if you are "watching" you will be able to clearly see the events unfold surrounding the Antichrist over the next several years. For you are now living in the time when the final manifestation of the Antichrist will soon appear!

[What an offer! Spanky is just oozing esoteric information on this vital subject.]

With all my heart, I pray that all of you whose hearts are right will be able to escape the coming Great Tribulation, the Trumpet Plagues of Revelation and finally the Seven Last Plagues—all destined to fall upon the followers of the Antichrist! So I have prepared for you an exciting booklet with biblical proof of the real nature of the Antichrist. I want to give you this booklet, upon your request. It may be the most precious gift that I could give you at this time in human history.

[Spanky, we’re all choked up!]

Somewhere on this earth today is a small, scattered and soon-to-be-persecuted Church. It is the "little flock" of whom Jesus spoke in Luke 12:32.

[Gosh, we wonder who they might be?]

But you, somehow, have been brought into contact with Jesus’ "little flock" which has the understanding and the courage to preach and to write the full Truth! We want to help you while we have the opportunity. We want to enable you and your loved ones to have God’s protection during the traumatic years just ahead, and to fulfill the awesome purpose for your lives.

[Oh, what a surprise, it’s Spanky and his little band of theological illiterates.]

Meantime the latest issue of the cult newsletter has two related stories: Prophetic Events Speed Up and Persecution is Coming! Both are by Meredith. And while Spanky and his pals may feel Afghanistan and terrorism are just "diversions", it didn’t stop Rod from claiming prescience on the matter.

"This Work – probably more than any other - has directly predicted that this type of terrorism would soon occur!"

Now if you want to see some really amazing "direct predictions", check out some of Rod’s greatest clangers on the LCG page.

UCG Council:  Credit where credit is due. The UCG seems to be doing a good job keeping members informed on the meeting of its Council of Elders in Clearwater, Florida. Minutes of the first days of the Council are online. If only el presidente Tkach would take note and practice even this modest level of open administration!

December 7

Greg Begs

If you would like to "store up...treasures in heaven" (Matthew 6:20) here are a few suggestions:

1) $10 will buy two Big Macs, fries and two large soft drinks AND $10 will
also help PTM print and mail 20 free booklets pointing people to the Bread of Life, to the One who can satisfy their spiritual hunger.

2) $15 will purchase two movie tickets and a bag of popcorn AND $15 can send 8 cassette tapes of our radio broadcast to first time callers responding to Plain Truth Commentary.

3) $25 is about what it costs to fill up the gas tank of a car AND $25 can
help write, edit, print, mail and distribute 50 free copies of Journey -
Meeting Life's Challenges.

WHY NOT make a difference in people's lives? WHY NOT help provide spiritual food and drink to those in desperate need?

PTM is looking for Partners who will join what thousands of others are
already doing - linking hands by financially contributing, storing up
investments in heaven, helping PTM help change lives of tens of thousands around the world.  Please give prayerful consideration to starting regular contributions - in whatever amount you can afford - to the ongoing work of PTM.  You will be contributing to helping make a lasting impact on the lives of other people.

Thank you, and may God bless you.
Greg Albrecht

Your Burger vs. Greg's Beamer: Dateline Pasadena: Recently Greg Albrecht sent out a letter to supporters of Plain Truth Ministries that contained some pretty absurd comments (see box).  Keep in mind that PTM aims to be totally self sufficient within the next year or so as WCG no longer wants to fund it.  The PT will carry a subscription fee for all, including any WCG members that want to receive it.  

The employees in Pasadena want to know why, if Greg expects people to give up a few luxuries in their lives to fund his ministry, he can't he give up his BMW?  That would fund thousands of subscriptions and cassette mailings.  Set the example Greg!  Show us that you practice what you preach! The same applies to your department heads, who have all been buying new vehicles recently. Need we say more?

Meredith - Another view: Dr. Bob Thiel gets our "Defender of the Faith" award for his efforts in attempting to lay to rest the various unflattering stories about Roderick C. Meredith in circulation. Bob is a host for a local LCG congregation, and, under the name COGwriter produces a popular pro-LCG site. Behind the scenes this last week there has been an exchange of emails between Dr. Thiel and Missing Dimension writer Gavin Rumney, initiated by Thiel who requested the removal of a quotation from John Tuit's book The Truth Shall Make You Free (we declined, and it can still be found on the LCG page). Thiel has put together a lengthy paper that seeks to debunk the negative material - some of it reported on this site, and other material that is new to us. We gather a shorter version has been sent out to LCG's ministry from San Diego HQ. Says Thiel: "When you try to do the work, Satan not only gets mad, but continues to act as "the accuser of the brethren"... Some of the false accusations are so absurd, that this article is not for the squeamish." Absurd? Decide for yourself.

The 10 charges Thiel rejects (the wording in italics is his):

(1) Roderick Meredith has a history of supporting false prophecies and should not be listened to. [Thiel essentially says "yes - to the first part - but..."]

(2) In the 1960s, Dr. Meredith was too hard on the field ministry and others [Thiel seems to say "yes, but not any longer"]

(3) Roderick Meredith is highly involved with pornography [Thiel: completely false]

"The fact is that Dr. Meredith has been the most faithful leader of any major Church of God group to proclaim the Gospel as a witness ...  Dr. Meredith has been faithful in word and deed."
Bob Thiel

(4) "He was proud of the fact that he spanked his teenage daughter on her bare backside at least once a week whether she needed it or not, just to keep her in line." [Quoted from Tuit's book. Thiel: false]

(5) Herbert Armstrong banished Roderick Meredith to Hawaii and wrote some negative things about him [Thiel: another "yes, but..."]

(6) Dr. Meredith made statements prior to the takeover by the GCG board which indicated there were no real problems [Thiel: "yes"]

(7) Roderick Meredith attempted to embezzle hundreds of thousands of dollars and was stopped by the board of the Global Church of God [Thiel: preposterous"]

(8) The majority of GCG Council Members removed Dr. Meredith from his position in GCG  [Thiel: false]

(9) In 1957, Dr. Meredith pressured Suzanne Black to be a 'special lady' for Herbert Armstrong for the purposes of providing sex and claimed that this was acceptable because HWA and GTA were 'above the law'  [Referring to material available on Steve's ESN page and reported here on the November 25 update. Thiel: "absurd, illogical, and potentially libelous"]

(10) Dr. Meredith is not an apostle, thus has no right to try to proclaim the Gospel  [Thiel: "yes - to the first part - but..."]

While we're far from convinced that Meredith emerges smelling of roses from this exercise even if we find Thiel's defense credible (and we have major reservations to say the least), we do encourage MD readers to check his article out in the interests of fairness. The Missing Dimension is referred to obliquely and quoted at several points without being named. We're also eager to hear from readers who have a response or comment to make to any of the  accusations Thiel refers to. The full article is at http://members.aol.com/cogwriter/rcm.htm 

Gerry Flurry - Mr. Sobriety: Has Gerry gone teetotal? The following quote from PCG's Royal Vision appears on the ESN site under a transcript of his inebriated 1993 encounter with local police officers.

We must examine ourselves for areas where we may be be holding back God’s work. Some of God’s people , for example, still drink too much alcohol. Yes, God sanctions and encourages the right use of alcohol. But I know that some people would be better off without it. I haven’t had a drink of alcohol in six years. Why? Because I felt I could be more effective in the work without it. Am I against alcohol? Of course not; I love to see people enjoy alcohol, as God instructs us. But if something is getting in your way, it is better to eliminate it. Royal Vision, July-August 2001

December 5

Spanky Babble: Does Rod Meredith actually listen to what he says himself, or are his rambling sermons so boring that he finds them as forgettable as his unfortunate listeners? This example of Meredith's inconsistency was sent in by an MD correspondent, and dates back to the heyday of Spanky's first designer-cult, the Global Church of God. Scene 1: a sermon. Rod is taking the moral high ground.

The people in Madison Avenue are always using women's bodies to sell everything from toothpicks to speedboats, you know, and so on. Getting these young girls that are dumb. And the young girls ought to know better. But the worst ones are the men that are older and take advantage of them.... And they don't fully grasp what they are doing; selling sex in a sense; causing young men to lust while they're supposedly selling these products. A bunch of stupidity and creating lust in the minds of millions of men in that way. So God says don't do these things (Roderick C. Meredith, "Law Based on Love," taped sermon, 24 April 1993).

That's reasonably clear. Now move ahead just a few months for Scene 2. Some of the same good folk who took those remarks very seriously have been amazed to find some provocative illustrations in Spanky's rag, The World Ahead, that breach the very principles he had so recently ranted about. Spanky responds:

A few members would rather we had not used the boy-girl-car at the beach photo [a provocative photo with a young girl in a skin-tight mini-dress sitting on the hood of a car], in Mr. Norman Edward's article [World Ahead, September 1993]. But one single, nonmember, 26-year-old woman said the dating behavior described in the article was 'typical' of the way it's done in the world today. The picture was what caused her to read the article! (This particular young lady needed to read that piece and get that point!) The World Ahead program and magazine are not primarily for the entertainment of the Global Church of God membership, but rather are directed to the world. Members should enjoy and profit from the program and WAM but the appeal must also be to the unconverted, if we are to carry out our commission to witness to the world. Members need to realize that a wide range of articles will have to be presented and that not every subject and or photo will be to everyone's liking. Let's keep our eyes on why we are here in the Global Church of God, not to turn inward but to reach the world!" (Global Church of God Ministerial, Deacon and Host Bulletin, 7 September 1993).

Now what was that proverb about a double-minded man? Our correspondent comments:

Per your question regarding Rod Meredith's sexual morals: Is he a hypocrite? Does he preach one thing and do another? Does he consider himself above the law? You be the judge.

Tom Lapacka: WCG to LCMS: Former Pasadena WCG minister Tom Lapacka moved out of the church in the mid-90s. In 1998 he resumed his ministry, this time as a pastor in the conservative Lutheran Church Missouri Synod. He has written a book on his WCG pilgrimage called Out of the Shadows: Finding God's Truth in a World of Deception. An excerpt:

Some in the WCG believe God put us through this experience so we would be ready to receive the truth. I strongly disagree with such sentiment because that implies our Lord led us into error so He could reveal the truth to us. The spirit leads us into truth, not error. No, we must come to grips with reality. We were deceived, in many cases willingly, because we desired to be special through the esoteric 'truths' that Herbert Armstrong preached. The Worldwide Church of God was a cult--of that there is no doubt. Whether theologically or psychologically, the WCG fit the classic definition of a cult. It is painful and embarrassing to admit, but it is a fact.

According to Amazon.com a new edition was due to be published in November by LCMS imprint Concordia Publishing House. 

December 4

Dateline Pasadena: From the West Pasadena Residents Association:

"Important Notice!

"On Thursday, November 15, 2001, the Transportation Advisory Commission (TAC) held a public hearing on the Legacy Project. The TAC meeting was well-attended, with at least 150 residents participating. In addition to the WPRA, the newly-formed organization, "Save South Orange Grove," gave a presentation highlighting the density of the Legacy Project. Mijares Restaurant also presented its concerns about traffic mitigation package "A". City officials stated that staff will formulate recommendations regarding density and traffic during the month of December, and will disclose these recommendations in January 2002. A planning Commission hearing will be set far enough in advance to permit other commissions (such as TAC) to review the Legacy Project and give their recommendations to the Planning Commission. According to City Planner Brian League, the review process for the Legacy Project will likely stretch well into Spring 2002."

Let there be (artificial) light: these little gems were passed on to us, and are too good not to share.

Q. How many Armstrongites does it take to change a light bulb?

A1. 1 to change the bulb and 10 to judge whether or not it was done right.

A2. 8, so that after 3 splits down the middle, the first 4 taking the money, the next 2 taking the ladder and the last 1 taking the supply of light bulbs, there is at least one person left to do all the work.

A3. Changing a bulb will cause a split in the church.  Some will leave declaring the light bulb should never be changed. Some will say that they predicted the light bulb was going to be changed.  Some will say that the way we measure light is not based upon the Bible but on Pharisaic tradition. Some will decry that they were not consulted on whether the light bulb actually needed changing.  Other will say the bulb changed itself and all the true electricians know it. Others will leave saying the whole house needs to be changed, not just the bulb. Another group will form to meet in the sunlight and declaring their relief from having to be lighted by bulbs. One group will start a media campaign to tell the world the story of light bulbs and how they should be changed. And lastly one group will form led by a man who claims that God did not tell him the light bulb needed to be changed so everyone involved is in revolt against God's government. All the new groups will have the word light, or bulb in their names except the more pretentious which will use luminescence.

Okay you creative types, any more submissions?

December 2

PCG and Petra: The carefully cultivated relationship between the PCG and officials in Jordan appears to have run onto the rocks, so to speak.  Petra, the ancient Jordanian rose-red rock city that draws thousands of camera-toting tourists each year is regarded by most traditional Armstrong followers as the coming "Place of Safety" where the "Philadelphia era" will be protected during the Great Tribulation.  In 1998 there was a major PCG Feast of Tabernacles venue in the Mid Eastern nation, but indications are that the Flurry cult is now no longer welcome.  Why?  One story in circulation concerns a sexual assault by a cult member on a Jordanian woman.

UCG conference agenda posted:  A detailed agenda for the upcoming week long UCG council meeting (beginning this Wednesday, December 5) has been posted by chairman Roy Holladay, along with a covering letter.  Presidential hopefuls will be put through their paces and reports received.  We encourage CEO Joe from the WCG to take a look with a view to running a more open operation in his own neck of the woods.

December 1

The Christmas Question:  A new poll is up on Xmas as the days count down and the jingles begin to assault our ears in the malls and supermarkets.  December 25 is now officially on the WCG’s calendar of festivals.  How do you feel about the day?  Click across to the poll page.

... and for Dr. Seuss fans here's a link to How The Grinch Stole Christmas.

November stats: Last month saw MD register over 17,000 hits, over 1000 more than October and the third record month in a row.  Total page views since May 8 now top 84,000 with visitors having come from 70 different countries.  The ten most viewed pages in November were (1) Update, (2) Home (3) Mail, (4) Polls, (5) Links, (6) Garner Ted Armstrong, (7) Splinters, (8) HWA & incest, (9) HWA biography, and (10) Flurry’s PCG.

November 30

COG7 ructions: Recently, high profile Church of God (Seventh Day) minister Steve Kurtright, a regular Bible Advocate contributor and lecturer at Summit School of Theology, resigned his ministry and membership with the Denver based denomination that ordained Herbert Armstrong in the 1930s. He released the following letter.

This communication is to inform you that Deborah and I have decided to resign our memberships with the General Conference of the Church of God (Seventh Day) effective immediately. I too am resigning from the ministry of the church after almost 30 years of service. Please remove us from all mailing lists.

After processing our spiritual and theological journey of the last six or eight years we concluded that we can no longer support the polity or works oriented doctrine of the church. We believe that we are saved by grace alone through Christ alone. We believe that sin is no longer our master because we are no longer under the law, but under grace (Romans 6: 14.)

It is my hope that one day the church will truly accept the gospel without qualification --that it will one day be truly Christ-centered and grace-based. For years Deborah has felt the need to ask God to forgive the church for its unwillingness to acknowledge the fullness of the gospel --asking God to bring repentance and renewal. However, we must be realistic and finally admit that a gospel-centered, Christ-centered church is the goal of very few. This is beyond sad.

Paul said that anyone (including himself or angels) bringing a gospel PLUS message perverts the gospel and is "eternally condemned" (Galatians 1:6-9.) The church's message historically has been a gospel plus message--the gospel plus Sabbath, tithing, clean meats, three days and three nights, correct Lord's Supper date, etc. Strides have been made, but the under girding theology of the church continues to struggle with a grace-based, Christ-centered message. This is evidenced by reactions to new Covenant articles appearing in the recent Forums and the NAMC resolution affirming the church's position regarding the Ten Commandments and Sabbath observance as a part of the new covenant. That is heresy.

We no longer believe that the covenant made at Sinai is binding on believers (2 Corinthians 3; Galatians 4:21-31 .) This includes the observance of the seventh-day Sabbath. We no longer believe Sabbath observance is binding on believers --Jesus is our Sabbath rest (Matthew 11 :28-30; Hebrews 4:9-11.) That conclusion has nothing to do with observing one day over the other. It is not a Sabbath or Sunday issue --it is a covenant issue. It is a gospel issue. It is a salvation issue. An issue we can no longer ignore.

As I take my leave I want to clarify some misinformation: The Conference did not fund any part of my education. I paid for all schooling necessary for my Master's degree.

I did not contribute to the divisions of the Houston (English) or the Shawnee Church after my pastorates. I served as pastor of the Houston Church for 18 years. That congregation continued to thrive for three years after my departure. I was not responsible for the decisions ultimately reached by core members to leave that congregation after that time. Certain core members in Shawnee were discouraged and ready to leave the church upon my arrival in the spring of 1993. I encouraged them to remain --they did so until some time after my move to Denver four years later. I did not use my influence to encourage them to start their own fellowship. That decision was theirs alone.

I did not teach contrary to the Church's doctrinal position while an instructor with Summit School of Theology. However, as a teacher I have a scriptural responsibility to teach truth (James 3:1.) Ultimately, I chose truth over my position.

We leave secure in our faith with no regrets. We embark on a life in which the gospel is the main thing. We affirm that the gospel is the good news that a loving God has taken the initiative to save us by grace alone, received through faith alone, based on the perfect life, atoning death and victorious resurrection of Jesus alone--plus nothing.

Steve and Deborah Kurtright September 25, 2001

New Flurry Page: The moderator of the PCG discussion group on Yahoo! has re-launched his web site on the Flurry church. It can be found at www.pcg_flurry.subnet.dk  Needless to say, this site is independent of the Oklahoma cult.

November 28

The evils of democracy: Just when you think the United Church of God is a thinking-person's version of Armstrongism, the sect's ministerial mullahs open their mouths and disconfirm any illusions. Here's an abridged version of an item by Mark Tabladillo posted today on his JLF Forum.

In the recent Journal (October 31, 2001), there is a front-page article about Ken Murray of Gatton, Australia. Ken has been suspended from his UCG-AIA ministerial duties because he ran (unsuccessfully) for political office.

For most of his working career, Ken has been a government employee, and in fact has held a local government office since March 2000, an office which he still holds. Ken was a paid WCG elder from 1982 to 1987, and was self-employed from 1987 to 1992. His specific UCG offense was choosing to run for Queensland state parliament as a nonpolitically aligned independent.

Not surprisingly, UCG-AIA came to its own opinion absent of any face-to-face process. Specifically, Murray believes the final decision was made by Roy Holladay, Dennis Luker, Leon Walker, and Australian office manager Reg Wright.

As is typical of the traditional WCG governmental process, UCG-AIA issued an initial official letter which stated in part:

Both the Pastoral Committee and the National Council are in agreement that, for the time being, while the matter is under further consideration and discussion, you will be temporally relieved of all ministerial duties and participation as a member of the National Finance Committee. We believe this to be the wise and correct decision to make at this time, out of concern for you personally, and also for the overall spiritual health of the brethren in this country.

Specifically, the written rationale given was:

The traditional historic teaching of the Church is that a Christian should not vote for, or themselves become candidates for, political office. This has been the continuous and consistent teaching of the Church. At no time has the Church taught anything to the contrary.

As is so often the case, "the church" will enforce its will. Reg Wright ends his letter with a request that Ken Murray come to some type of "repentance" (remember Raymond McNair???) and perform these verbal acts of contrition for himself and Graemme Marshall.

What does Ken have to repent of, we wonder? And will UCG also discipline non-ordained members who dare aspire to political office? As for repenting to Marshall, I personally well remember a "baptismal counseling" session with this great man of God, along with his underling John Comino, some years ago. Mr. Marshall, then director of the New Zealand "Work" ranted Nazi-style about the evils of inter-racial marriage and the blessings of apartheid and segregation. Satan, Marshall opined, had inspired the lyrics to a popular song with a chorus that began "what we need is a great big melting pot."  Ah, the good old days...

The JLF ("Jesus Loves Fellowship") Forum can be found at delphi.com. It has a deserved reputation for being one of the most pleasant and balanced places for discussion of WCG matters. A truncated edition of The Journal can be found at www.thejournal.org

Spanky and Hulme bomb in poll: Here are the results of our poll on which Church of God sects are expected to survive through the next twenty years. Interesting that the only non-Armstrong group on the list tops the poll easily. MD readers - obviously a perceptive group - seem to not expect the LCG to survive once "Presiding Evangelist" Meredith has passed from the scene. The WCG comes in under 10%

Which of these Church of God groups is likely to still be around in 2020?

Church of God (Seventh Day)
United Church of God
Worldwide Church of God
Philadelphia Church of God
Church of God AIC (Hulme)
Living Church of God

45.90%
36.07%
09.84%
08.20%
00.00%
00.00%

There were 61 responses to this poll

University hits grow: Some months ago we put together a list of university domains that Hitbox has identified as logging in to The Missing Dimension. The list has just been updated and can now be found on a separate page. Herb may have been a high school dropout, but there seems no end of academic interest in the ad-man turned evangelist and his legacy.

November 26

More on Wiley & Suzanne Black: The following testimonial appeared on the JLF Forum today in response to the potentially explosive developments covered in yesterday's "Chickens fly home to roost" item:

Wiley Black was one of my Imperial School teachers and he and his wife are very nice people. Wiley and Suzanne were some of the only ones many of the Imperial kids felt like they could talk to when things got really bad at home or school. Wiley was probably the most favorite teacher Imperial Big Sandy ever had because he treated us with dignity and respect. 

November 25

Chickens fly home to roost: A remarkable document has appeared online chronicling the testimonies of Wiley and Suzanne Black, a couple who have decided to share their story of WCG abuse. Both were members of the church and AC students. Mr. Black, now 80 years old, taught at Imperial Schools in Big Sandy and later at Ambassador College. Their certified statements appear in a publication called "The Bible Expositor", produced by Bernard Kelly.

Among other things, Suzanne Black relates how Rod Meredith attempted to enlist her, while a student at AC in 1957, as one of Herbert Armstrong's "special ladies".

I had been reared in a strict moral church background, and I had no idea "what" a "special lady" was! Rod [Meredith] proceeded to tell me, that true men of God, had stronger than usual "Sex Drives", and that that was what motivated them to be God's true ministers, apostles, etc. And, since HWA was his (God's) TOP apostle on earth, that HE had the strongest sex drive of any man alive on earth. And, that while normally the church didn't allow men to have other women, other than their wives, that in the case of certain of God's chosen men, it was OK... since HWA, his son, Garner Ted Armstrong, and others, were ***ABOVE THE LAW***!  He recited to me many instances in the Bible, where great men of God had had MANY women... like King Saul, King David, Moses, Abraham, etc...

I was also informed by Rod Meredith, that there were ONLY three top positions available, in God's Work, and that those were already filled... the top position going to HWA, the 2nd position to GTA, and he, himself (Rod Meredith) filled the 3rd position, and ALWAYS WOULD... for all eternity!!!

On refusing, Suzanne was, according to her notarized statement, ostracized by church leaders. 

Mr. Black's statement includes the following account:

Guy Carnes... related to us... that Armstrong knew most, if not all, of his prophecies were fraudulent and even how Armstrong 'fabricated' the idea of a 'place of safety' called Petra!

Carnes claimed that Armstrong's wife, Loma, happened to be reading an article in the National Geographic Magazine about the Jordanian 'Red Rock' city called Petra and immediately said to Herbert that Petra would be the perfect place to 'claim' that it would be God's 'place of safety' for His people before the bombs started to fall in 1972!  Herbert agreed that this would be another good tactic to keep the 'dumb sheep', members of his church under constant 'fear' of not making it to Petra if they didn't toe the mark!

If authentic, these must be some of the most damning indictments of Armstrong's ministry to date. The documents were released online today by the Exit & Support Network and are available on Steve's page

Rod Denies Spanking and Porn Claims: Twenty years after John Tuit published information about Rod Meredith's alleged obsession with spanking and pornography, we have been advised that Meredith has categorically denied them. In 1981 Tuit wrote:

In a sermon he once went to great lengths to explain how people should spank their children. He was proud of the fact that he spanked his teenage daughter on her bare backside at least once a week whether she needed it or not, just to keep her in line. His penchant for X-rated movies and adult book stores has been explained by him as a necessary part of his research in order that he may speak out properly against such sins in his sermons. 

A leading LCG member personally approached Meredith about Tuit's statements after reading about them on this site. Meredith denied them flatly. The LCG member then contacted us.

I spoke with Dr. Meredith yesterday, as well as both of his daughters, all separately, to verify what I am about to tell you.  

1. Dr. Meredith has never viewed an X-rated movie.  
2. He has never been in a X-rated bookstore.  
3. He has no involvement with pornography.  
4. He never made any of the statements that Tuit attributes to him.
5. He never spanked either of his teenage daughters on their bare backsides.

We have every reason to believe in the sincerity of the individual who wrote these words. Meredith's denials have, however, not convinced several sources who we've approached:

Meredith's porno and spanking habits were well known in Pasadena. He bragged about his daughter's paddy-whackings from the pulpit! People saw him coming out of porno book stores, and he would claim he was doing research!

Another correspondent states:

... my daughter was in one of his classes when she attended AC in Pasadena and she told me she had never sat in the class of a teacher who was so dirty minded and obsessed with sex... The guy has no discernment of what is really proper to say in public.  As for being seen coming out of a porn shop and spanking his daughter's bare behind,  that was common knowledge in the last years before I left the cult.

Anyone who has suffered through one of Meredith's long rambling sermons certainly knows the truth behind the statement that he has no discernment of what is really proper to say in public. So, who are we to believe?  We'd be interested to hear from readers who have further information.

November 21

Ron's Report: Controller Ron Kelly writes in the December WN:

Most of you are aware that our desire is to implement a new WCG financial model. This plan will provide for congregations to have a large percentage of their donations attributed to or remain in each local church bank account. We had hoped that escrow would have closed before now and that implementation of the new model could begin in early 2002.

However, the earliest we can now expect to close on the property sale is late March [don't hold your breath Ron, late March is looking VERY optimistic indeed!]. In order to implement the plan at the beginning of 2002, escrow needed to close long before now. These delays affect implementation of the new financial model.

We appreciate your patience as we move through what has proved to be a slow process. Those of us who work on these matters day-to-day are anxious to conclude the sale and move on with the new financial plan for our congregations. But until the Pasadena property sells we are limited in what we can accomplish.

We are holding our heads above water, but continue to use reserve funds for a portion of operating capital. As of Oct. 31 we have transferred $4.4 million of our reserves this year to maintain our expense budgets... This is a good time to evaluate tax implications and consider generous year-end giving to assist the church.. What a wonderful God and Father we have who allows us to share in the work he is doing to proclaim Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior.

Yes Ron, it certainly is a deeply meaningful privilege to be able to send money in so the church can continue to disenfranchise its members with a hierarchical structure resembling something out of the Middle Ages, along with a stunning lack of accountability. Thanks so much for offering us the opportunity!

click to enlarge

Believe it or not department: The January/February issue of The Plain Truth is going to feature a lead article called - we kid you not - Fundamentalism—Breeding Ground for Fanaticism.  Um, let's see, is that Joe's picture on the front cover, or The Bible Answer Man's? 

Festivals 2002: Also in the WN are dates for the WCG's "festivals" for next year. Here's the list. 

Tuesday, March 26: Lord’s Supper. Thursday, March 28: First Day of Unleavened Bread, Maundy Thursday. Friday, March 29: Good Friday. Sunday, March 31: Easter. Wednesday, April 3: Last Day of Unleavened Bread. Sunday, May 19: Day of Pentecost. Saturday, Sept. 7: Feast of Trumpets. Monday, Sept. 16: Day of Atonement. Saturday, Sept. 21: First Day of the Festival of Tabernacles. Saturday, Sept. 28: Last Great Day of the Festival. Sunday, Dec. 1: First day of Advent. Wednesday, Dec. 25: Christmas.

That's quite some liturgical calendar guys. Can we all say eclectic together?

November 20

More Grief for Sale Process: The word is that all those prayers for a speedy sale of the WCG Pasadena headquarters have boomeranged back and clobbered the petitioners, leaving a nasty lump on the bonce. The following items were posted on the JLF Forum today, and have been slightly edited.

The latest "kick in the teeth" for the Ambassador Project comes with the Pasadena Planning Commission getting an earful from local residents who have formed two new groups to fight the development (this is aside from the West Pasadena Residents Association.) The lawyers and even a traffic expert are being brought in. Residents are furious with the ever-changing project. Because of the pressure on the Planning Commission, there is now no way that escrow will close in March as HQ had hoped.

Yet more gloomy news.

Two of the three remaining auditorium employees will be laid off on Pearl Harbor Day (Dec. 7).

And from Dateline Pasadena

There have been several community groups that have really been upset with the entire Ambassador Project... Bill Schubin is a slick, smooth talker.  He could run for president easily.  He is an excellent politician.  He can get up in front of a group of angry people and have them  praising him up one side and down the other before he is through.  In the mean time, he has not addressed their questions, yet they think he has.

The local community think the church is stupid for not leasing the property instead of selling it. If they held perpetual lease rights, they would have a guaranteed income forever.  People could build what they want and the church collect the rent money for the land.  All the major office buildings and stores in Pasadena are on leased land.  This also includes most of the housing complexes here. The public is fighting for the gardens and open spaces to be maintained and Legacy reluctantly agreed to it.

Regarding the Auditorium crew.  All three of them are staunch Armstrong supporters.  They feel that they are maintaining the House of God that Armstrong built...  They would have fits whenever WCG would have services there and sing songs beside those Dwight Armstrong wrote, or if the church sang Christmas songs or decorated for Christmas.  They constantly have a stream of former members that hate the changes in the WCG coming to visit them... They are also of the opinion that we are in the famine of the Word, that this is end time prophecy being fulfilled before their eyes.  So they feel that it is up to them and a small group of supporters to preserve in any manner they can anything associated with HWA.

The first scheduled season is planned for 2004.  Legacy wants to have only a couple of events in the Auditorium each year till that time.  Then, once the endowment fund is set up, they will start looking for people to run it.  Since many events will be on Friday nights and Saturdays, none of the present crew would work those days.

Mongo Frumblefoot of Bywater

Herbert Armstrong

Ponto Millstone of Bywater

Gerald Flurry

Bolo Chubb-Baggins

Joseph Tkach

Togo Toadfoot

Bernie Schnippert

Berilac Hardbottle

Michael Feazell

Drogo Sackville-Bracegirdle

David Pack

Bungo Knotwise of Michel Delving

Dibar Apartian

Drogo Danderfluff of Willowbottom

David Hulme

And Now For Something Completely Different:  All this talk of layoffs, real estate woes, Calvinism and Dennis Luker as church president... it's enough to drive even a Salvation Army officer to drink!  We decided to lighten up with our own Missing Dimension tribute to the upcoming movie Lord of the Rings.  Ah yes, someone is sure to scream "demonism!" or something equally ludicrous.  In fact grizzle-guts Garner Ted Armstrong, that eminent child-rearing expert, has already pounced on Harry Potter.  But do we care?  Click across to this evil pagan site and acquire your very own Hobbit name!  Meantime, here are some hobbitized names of the WCG's most esteemed dignitaries, past and present.

Come to think of it, when Herb shook his jowls on TV, didn't he look just a tad hobbit-like?  Or perhaps we have hobbits confused with Orcs...

November 18

Herb the Crypto-Calvinist: What does Armstrong-type millennialism ("The World Tomorrow") have to do with dour traditional Calvinism? Perhaps more than we once thought. That's certainly the conclusion that Robert K. Whalen reaches in a paper delivered to the 3rd annual conference of the Center for Millennial Studies. Call us slow, but we've just come across this 1998 essay, and it gives pause for thought.

Not that Whalen mentions Herb or the WCG directly. But the Adventist roots of the Worldwide Church of God are well known. And you don't have to be any kind of Adventist to have delusions about the end of the world being just around the corner. Whalen coins the term "Watched-Pot" eschatology (eschatology is the study of the Last Things) to describe this phenomena.

You remember, of course, the old adage that "A watched pot never boils." Still, that it will boil – eventually -- seems certain. The irresistible temptation is to search the pot for signs of a boil. The tension lies in anticipation. It is this pleasant psychic tension which marks evangelical eschatology in America, not the lurid date-setting of the Millerites nor the denatured and defanged apocalypse of Mainline Protestantism.

Herb and chums, of course, were into a bit of the "lurid date-setting", but quickly wiped their mouths and pleaded innocence when confronted with the evidence.

For the first two centuries of American history, Calvinism undergirt both popular and scholarly religiosity in America. Early in the nineteenth-century, though, it began to falter. Such a rigorous belief lay a heavy burden on the faithful...

For generations of Calvinists the question of salvation before an awful God was like a decayed tooth in the mouth over which one could not – metaphorically speaking – resist moving the tongue, try as one might. It was torment – but too delicious, too fascinating, to be resisted. Endless watching for signs of grace kept the believer in a constant and excruciating, but endlessly beguiling, agony. Resolution of that agony of anticipation depended entirely on when, and if, an utterly sovereign God intervened to select one out of the world of sin.

So what is the connection between Calvinism, WCG and the other diverse end-timers ranging all the way from Billy Graham through to the latter-day Rapture crowd? Whalen finds that the first American millenarianists were deeply suspicious of democracy and change. They were often successful men who were keen on defending the status quo (including slavery) and the advantages it bestowed on them.

In 1855 the president of Dartmouth College, a prominent premillennialist, warned that the world "cannot be governed by one, or a few, or the many. All despotisms, aristocracies, democracies, especially fail."  A few years later he railed before the Dartmouth student body against "the dream of self-government," and damned those who would reform society according to "their own socialistic ideas, which are but ideas, visionary and impracticable in a fallen state."  Later, this same man wrote long pamphlets in defense of slavery, attacked the Emancipation Proclamation, and was finally forced from office by the Dartmouth College trustees, who were embarrassed by his social obduracy. Two concepts encompassed his reactionary social views, Calvinism and eschatology -- and they blended seamlessly. Since man is morally powerless social reform is a delusion and the creation of a just society must await Christ’s return in fire and judgment. The moral inability of each man under Calvinism is thus transformed via eschatology into the social inability of all men. God’s sovereignty is preserved. Man’s inability is reaffirmed. Calvinism survives. The status quo continues.

... we see a dramatic instance of the transference of theology into eschatology. Where the Calvinist searched endlessly for signs of grace as an indication of God’s intervention in his life, he now searched the world for signs of God’s intervention in history. Some signs were significant – such as the fall of the French Monarchy. Others were less so -- such as an increase in "the malign biting off of noses," a portent identified by the Prophetic Times (and it alone) in 1866... The psychological tension felt by the Christian over whether he was predestined for salvation was transferred into a group tension over when the Lord would return.

(As a side note, a publication called Prophetic Times is in fact still being published - not surprisingly by the United Church of God - although we're not aware of any reports of recent nose-biting!)

American evangelicalism, unlike Mainline Protestant thought, retains eschatology in its core theology. This came to pass as Calvinism survived by migrating into eschatology. The two systems of thought worked together like matched sine waves to amplify and preserve one another.

Whalen marshals a good deal of evidence to support his case (which seems a strong one to us). The full seven-page academic paper, in PDF format, is available online.  If Whalen is correct, the enthusiasm many WCG members once felt for an impending close of history in 1972 was caused simply by passing under a chilly shadow cast by John Calvin's blighted theology.

November 16

And then there were five: The UCG has "pared back" its list of presidential hopefuls to five. They are: Roy Holladay, Clyde Kilough, Dennis Luker, Les McCullough and Richard Pinelli. 

Another pilgrim on the path: Robin Brace, a WCG member from 1981-1994, recently contacted us. Now a Baptist minister in the UK and the holder of an honors degree in theology, Mr. Brace has launched an MSN communities site called Museltof Christian Ministries.

November 14

Liberation or lobotomy? The Los Angeles Times published a review of Michael Feazell's book "The Liberation of the Worldwide Church of God" in its November 10 edition. Written by Mark Kellner, who confesses to being a member back in the 70s, it provides an accurate if uncritical background to the book. For those who want a less easy-going assessment, we draw your attention to the review on this site

November 13

From: Janet Shay [mailto:Janet.Shay@wcg.org]
Sent: Monday, November 12, 2001 11:00 AM
To: hqemployees@wcg.org
Subject: Early Closing Today!

Joseph Tkach has authorized employees to leave work at 3:00 p.m. today as a Veterans Day observance.  In light of recent events, please reflect on the dedicated service and sacrifices our veterans and military personnel have given. Employees who are scheduled to work after 3:00 p.m. will be paid for the remainder of their shifts.  Our offices will reopen at 8:00 a.m. Tuesday. Please notify staff and co-workers who don't have e-mail.   Janet Shay Human Resources x5362

Generous Joe, the Ideal Employer: Working for the WCG naturally means experiencing millennial conditions of employment. Take Veterans Day for example. Most businesses close down on Monday if it falls on Sunday.  Not WCG though.  The lucky church employees - those that survived the last cost cutting purge - got to come in as usual and stay through till 3.00. How considerate!  From Dateline Pasadena

While WCG now supports the military and has no problem with members serving in the armed forces, church bosses decided that the serfs should keep their noses to the grindstone.  But what really astounded many employees was the fact that most of the administrators were already taking the day off.  These selfless "servants of God" rarely show up to work on Mondays or Fridays.  Let the peons do the work, while they spend time on the golf course or pottering around their newly purchased and built homes.

It's tough at the top!

Brian's Barbarians: Why wait for the latest issue of The Journal? You can read Brian Knowles' latest column, The Barbarians are again at the Gates, online. We have to disagree with Brian, however, when he says:

The stage was long ago set for this attack [9/11]. It was set by subversion from within. Those who have sought to undermine the Constitutional underpinnings of this great nation set the stage. It was incrementally set by subversive ideas like moral relativism, political correctness, celebrating "diversity" (i.e. idolatry), and the legalizing of immoral behavior. The downgrading of patriotism and conservatism played a role. The relentless denigration of Christian and Jewish values represented a major contribution.

Celebrating diversity is idolatry? Go figure. We kind of like diversity. And its an acceptance of diversity that allows freedom of religion to flourish - and people like Brian (and us!) to express a view. The last really big crackdown on diversity was called The Dark Ages. The former Plain Truth editor also had a major article published in the October Bible Advocate

November 12

Love and Unity - Spanky Style: The Living Church of God has concluded a simply wonderful meeting of its Council of Elders. That's if you believe Carl McNair's November 8 report. Carl gushes about the "unanimous consensus... the pleasure of being together again. The deep love and camaraderie shared..." And it gets better! "Mr. Meredith (presiding) introduced each agenda item and solicited comments and input from every member. Where there was a difference of opinion, it was fully explored and either resolved or a decision deferred until further information is available."

Could it be that Spanky's rigid cult has miraculously transformed into a sensitive new age community? Apparently not. Having delivered the paean of praise, McNair returns to reality:

The Council of Elders for Living Church of God was established to advise and assist the Presiding Evangelist on administrative and doctrinal issues. The Living Church of God government is hierarchical, not congregational. In the Church, there are ADMINISTRATIVE decisions that the Church leader must make for the whole body-and once those decisions are rendered it is the duty of the ministry to implement them as effectively as possible. Doctrinal decisions are also made for the whole Church, to keep us walking together harmoniously. The Presiding Evangelist, with counsel from the Council of Elders during these and other meetings, makes decisions for the whole body and it is the duty of the ministry to teach those doctrines in faith that God has guided the leadership (see I Timothy 4:1-13).

Unity in the LCG Council of Elders is no problem. They just do what Rod says. And who could Carl be referring to with these comments?

Unfortunately, in the scattered fragments of the former Worldwide Church of God, there is a cacophony of voices proclaiming major and minor differences of opinion and "wind of doctrine." Many of those voices have no credibility when their personal example of living is known-but reading their critiques on doctrine does not always show their personal history of disobedience to God’s Law.

Yup, the "personal example" of some "voices" is really disturbing. Herb Armstrong, for example, who set the all-time low standard in matters of "disobedience to God's Law" with alcoholism and incest.

Meanwhile out in Modesto: Don Billingsley is apparently recovering from another brush with foot-in-mouth disease.

The question has been asked of me as to whether in my previous writing I was saying that Osama bin Laden and his terrorists may bring about the Great Tribulation?  I am sorry if some misunderstood my writing about the havoc these terrorists are causing in this country to possibly believe this sets aside what the Bible reveals as to who will be bring the downfall of Israel. 

Aaron Dean Bolts in: There was no doubt about who MD readers don't want to see as UCG president. Congratulations Aaron, it can't be easy to bring down a resounding result like that! The poll is now closed.

Which candidate would you most NOT want to see selected as UCG President?

Aaron Dean
Dennis Luker
Gary Antion

Matt Fenchel

Clyde Kilough
Les McCullough
Richard Pinelli
Roy Holladay
Jim O'Brien

41.67%
19.44%
11.11%
05.56%
05.56%
05.56%
05.56%
02.78%
02.78%

There were 36 responses to this poll

November 9

Recycling the House of God: Dateline Pasadena: "Tonight in the Auditorium, Legacy Partners put on a concert trying to entice specially selected Pasadena residents and arts groups to help finance and run the Ambassador Auditorium when they (Legacy) turn it over to the City of Pasadena (as a gift). Here is what was in the program tonight. The Auditorium is going to be renamed Ambassador Hall. That will mean they will be scraping the gold letters of the dedication off the rose onyx wall. That is sure to send many in the various splinter groups into a tizzy."

A Plan For the Future

 

Reopening of the Ambassador Auditorium

Opened in April 1974, and closed as a major performing arts venue in May of 1995, the acoustically perfect Ambassador Auditorium is poised to once again welcome international as well as local musicians and performing artists. Throughout its 20-year history, the auditorium hosted over two-and-a-quarter-million people for some 2,500 concerts.  Among the world renowned concert artists to perform in this elegant hall were Vladimir Horowitz, Carlo-Maria Giulini and the Vienna Symphony, Luciano Pavarotti, Mistaslav Rostropovich, Mel Torme, Bing Crosby, Sarah Vaughn, Pearl Bailey, Ella Fitzgerald, Marcel Marceau, Herbert von Karajan and Dizzy Gillespie.

To reopen the elegant 1,250 seat auditorium, Legacy Partners, the proposed developer for the Ambassador site, is seeking approval from the City of Pasadena to form a Community Facilities District (CFD) that will allow Legacy to gift the Ambassador Auditorium, and the necessary improvements, to the City.  The City of Pasadena will then issue a bond with the sources of repayment coming from a special tax placed on each parcel of the 48-acre East and West Campuses which make up the new development.  Only residents of this property will be assessed this special tax.

In addition, Legacy Partners and the City of Pasadena will complete an agreement to provide approximately 400 parking spaces in a multi-use parking structure adjacent to the auditorium on the corner of Green Street and St. John Street for use by the auditorium patrons.  The structure will also include a ground level ticket office as well as administrative offices for the auditorium.

In recent months, Legacy Partners has been working with a distinguished group of local citizens to form the Ambassador Hall Board of Directors. Committed to bringing back world class entertainment, while also making the auditorium available to local concert artists and performances, the Board of this new non-profit corporation has presented the City of Pasadena with its business plan and is preparing to create an endowment that will cover the operating expenses of the auditorium well into the future.  And what a future it promises to be!

The following artists performed tonight for the program.

Alkabu-lan Boy Choir
Suzanna Guzman  Mezzo Soprano
Vitaly Margulis  Pianist from Russia

A video presentation of past Auditorium highlights was shown.  It was
narrated by actor Michael York

The following people are on the new Ambassador Hall Board of Directors.

Alice Coulombe President
Stephen Ascher
Ernest Camacho
Julie Campoy
Richard Colburn
Don Conlan
James Ellis
Heather Haaga
Carol Henry
Betty Ho
Angela Holberton
Maurice Katz
Judith Kelly
Robert Lawrence Kuhn   (yes, the Robert Kuhn of old WCG)
Harold Meyerman
Kathryn Nack
Violet Ouynag
David Partridge
Versie Richardson
Ann Rothenberg
Elsie Sadler
J. Patrick Whaley
Ian White-Thomson
Cathy Woolway


More information and to be put on the mailing list, contact:
The Ambassador Project
671 South Catalina Avenue
Pasadena, CA  91106

UCG News: The latest issue of United News is out. A front page story notes that 18,740 people kept the UCG Feast this year.

At 47 UCG sites around the world, more than 18,000 celebrated the Feast of Tabernacles this year, an 11 percent increase over last year. The largest part of this increase is from the 1,000 members formerly of the Remnant Church of God in Ghana who have joined with United. The increase in attendance for the United States and Canada was 4.8 percent.

There is also further information on the process for appointing a new president.

By November 9 each Council member will nominate a maximum of two people from the list [of nominees] with a written statement supporting each choice. Anyone not nominated at this time will be taken off the list...

February 28, 2002: Elect new president at Council meeting in Cincinnati... May: Incoming president assumes responsibilities at Annual Meeting of the General Conference of Elders.

Our special poll on the UCG presidency will finish after the weekend. Unless you're a member of the General Conference of Elders, it will be the only vote you get. While we acknowledge that UCG has a more accountable structure than WCG, we have to wonder why the General Conference structure excludes member participation. In our view all stakeholders have a right to representation, not just the salaried ministry.

November 8

Six Months in a Leaky Boat (with apologies to Split Enz): Today marks the 6-month anniversary of The Missing Dimension since it was re-launched in its present form. According to Hitbox (who provide our statistics) we’ve had in excess of 71,000 page views logged since then, with visitors coming from 64 different countries. We’re consistently ranked among the top 50 New Zealand-based web sites registered with Hitbox (# 27), and among the top 100 religion sites they monitor (# 76). Modest achievements, but very encouraging for a site that deals exclusively with an obscure religious movement that most people have never heard of.

Tithing Editorial: There’s a new editorial up on the subject of tithing. Our thanks to guest writer M.A.M. who provided this stimulating piece, which includes a new way of viewing the famous "cheerful giver" passage in 2 Corinthians 9:7.

Leader of the Pack: In what may be an apocryphal tale, a group of ex-WCGers was discussing the smorgasbord of offshoots now touting their wares. One mentioned Dave Pack’s hard-line RCG cult. Another asked what the "R" in RCG stood for. Quick as a flash the third replied "Retarded!"

While it’s an appealing answer, in the interests of accuracy we regret to advise that it’s nonetheless an incorrect one (as is "repressed".) The Restored Church of God is a breakaway from Global, and resembles the Flurry cult in a number of ways, especially in its insistence on what many consider mind-numbing conformity.

The Great Ambassador Real Estate Fiasco: The very name West Pasadena Residents' Association must send a shudder down the spines of the WCG's longsuffering accountants. The well-heeled members of WPRA have definite views on the disposition of the Ambassador campus. Check out their website

Another good place to get an overview of the Ambassador campus brouhaha is the recently revamped Duckys Village, a site aimed at former Ambassador employees.

Painless URL: The Painful Truth has been a leading source for information on the Worldwide Church of God and its "colorful history" for a long time. Now the site is sporting a new easy-to-remember URL on a new server. The link is www.wwwcg.info/. And there are no ad banners!

November 4

Flaky Flurry’s Potluck Paganism: Life in the alternate universe created by Gerald Flurry can be, well, different. A former PCG member posted this question online recently:

What's the silliest thing you ever heard in the church? … I think in the St Louis area, the silliest thing would be the prohibition on using the word "luck", because of its pagan origins and supposedly implied that God wasn't in charge. Therefore, all meals that consisted of various foods brought by many different people had to be referred to as: POTBLESSING!!

Apparently the PCG minister wouldn’t allow the word "fortune" either, as "the root word had to do with telling your fortune by the stars, in other words fortunate = astrology." Whoa!

Hawks and Doves: The results of the poll on Christians and War came as a bit of a surprise. The Church of God tradition has been anti-war since its earliest days, and members have refused to bear arms in the American Civil War through to recent times. Here's how the votes went.

Should a Christian participate in the military?

No, it is inconsistent with Christ's teachings
Yes, it is a duty to fight for one's country
Only in extreme circumstances

The decision remains with the individual

19.44%
19.44%
08.33%
52.78%

There were 36 responses to this poll

The new poll concerns the eager nominees lining up to contest the UCG presidency. We thought we'd do things a bit differently and ask you who you'd least like to see in the job. Early indications are strongly pointing in the direction of one nominee in particular. 

November 2

God Didn't Do It! Or Did He?  UCG president Les McCullough's latest letter has us confused. "There is a question which arises: Is God punishing us for our sins? The follow-up is, Did God cause it [9/11] to come about? My opinion is only my opinion, but I do not believe God caused it to happen. It is apparent that He did allow it to happen." Hmmm. McCullough goes on to say:

The Church of God does believe there is a time coming when God will indeed punish the United States and other nations of the world. Jeremiah was told by God, "And it shall be, when you show this people all these words, and they say to you, ‘Why has the Lord pronounced all this great disaster against us? Or what is our iniquity? Or what is our sin that we have committed against the Lord our God?’ Then you shall say to them, ‘Because your fathers have forsaken Me,’ says the Lord; ‘they have walked after other gods and have served them and worshiped them, and have forsaken Me and not kept My law’" (Jeremiah 16:10-11).

There is a primary reason God punished the ancient nation of Israel. Read it in Nehemiah 13:17-18. “Then I contended with the nobles of Judah, and said to them, ‘What evil thing is this that you do, by which you profane the Sabbath day? Did not your fathers do thus, and did not our God bring all this disaster on us and on this city? Yet you bring added wrath on Israel by profaning the Sabbath.’"  

We as a nation are equally guilty of profaning the Sabbath day and turning from the God of our fathers. What He has punished for in the past, He will punish for in the future. We have a responsibility to carry the warning to our nation as much as we can. We don't want to see our nation punished and crushed by some foreign power, but it will happen if we don't repent. Nineveh is the only nation on record to have repented and changed after being warned. Would that we could become a second one, but that doesn't appear likely.

It then goes without saying that we as the spiritual people of God need to be very aware and concerned about the Sabbath day and the other laws of God. The more one knows, the more that is required of the individual.

Let's get this straight. God permits people to die grisly deaths because they go to church on the wrong day? And sometime soon he's going to start killing people for the same reason? Sheesh!

A Day at the Races: They're lining up in the 2001 UCG presidential cup, awaiting the starters gun. In lanes one to nine are: Gary Antion, Aaron Dean, Matt Fenchel, Roy Holladay, Clyde Kilough, Dennis Luker, Les McCullough, Jim O’Brien and Richard Pinelli. There are clouds overhead, a downpour is expected and the track is already heavy. 

Roy Holladay has been getting in some extra practice by firing out his own presidential-style missives in his present capacity as Chairman. According to his latest letter the council meets in early December to, among other matters, interview the presidential hopefuls, discuss doctrinal issues, review the member assistance program, set money aside for church buildings and view a presentation on counseling homosexuals. 

Papa Joe Prays without ceasing: Also in epistle writing mood is the WCG's un-elected president-for-life. "My prayers for your comfort and courage in the gospel have not ceased since the horrific events of September 11," writes Joe Junior in a mildly unctuous November member letter. While Joe goes on to sensibly caution the flock about prophetic speculation (Les, take note!), one can only wonder at the paternalistic assumption of smug spiritual superiority that seems to underlie his approach. Are Joey’s prayers of special merit? Are the brethren supposed to be delighted, calmed and comforted by his pontifical feat of intercession? If anything, the apostolic chair seems to be getting cranked up even higher over the heads of the membership. That, however, can pose its own dangers. Perhaps Joe never read "Yertle the Turtle" in his deprived WCG childhood.

And of course no member letter would ever be complete without a plea for the plebs to pay up! "Brothers and sisters, the work of the church is more important than ever as people are afraid and uncertain and looking for answers. Please continue to remember our collective financial needs as we work together to share Christ’s good news. We do need your help, in prayer and in giving, to be faithful to God’s calling." Hey, wait a minute: "as we work together"? Anyone might think the Pastor General was referring to some meaningful involvement of members in the decision-making processes of the church. Joe, please tell us it's so!

November 1

More on life in the PCG: Another survivor story recently posted on a discussion forum

I had been in the "live" audience on Pentecost, with Flurry live and in person, and he kept going on and on about his new prophecy "the last hour" and at the same time he made a lot of snide remarks about his wife's emotional problems caused by menopause. Then a few weeks later his son gave a message about "the last hour", and how we weren't supposed to surf the net, waste time watching TV, pray at the times he said to pray (morning, noon, and sunset, never at night), and we couldn't stay up past midnight without a minister's permission. I knew I couldn't live like that... there was actually a woman who died this year because of the healing doctrine, in our local congregation...

The Caretaker takes a Hoeh ride: The Graveyard Church of God, cheeky brainchild of "The Caretaker", continues to provide surprises. Here's a fascinating article (new to us, but it's probably been up for a good while) that reminisces on the old time WCG. Comments about Herman Hoeh (pronounced "hay") and Gerald Waterhouse may bring a smile of recognition. An excerpt:

As one of only a few PhD's AC granted, Dr. Hoeh was a top evangelist and right-hand man to God's apostle, Herbert W. Armstrong. Dr. Hoeh's doctoral thesis was known simply as "The Compendium." I never knew anyone who had seen a copy, let alone read it... Consensus by the ones who knew someone who read it was that is was good - really good - but hard to understand. It was written at an intellectual level far above the majority of the church members; it was said to say wise things because it was written by a wise man who spent time in thought on very deep thoughts... For Dr. Hoeh was the Church Einstein and lived the role to its fullest. He spoke in slow, measured tones and paused a lot between his sentences. Apparently, deep-thoughted people do this. He often repeated things for effect and the effect was quite scholarly. He wore ill-fitting, out-of-date suits and never, ever, ever dressed casual and never, ever, ever socialized. He simply must be smart because he had a PhD and never had anything to do with the laity. The missing teeth only magnified the effect of a man possessed with knowledge rather than material goods.

After he spoke, the audience was very impressed but never quite sure of exactly what he had said. He took us from point A to point B quite logically, or so it seemed, but everyone invariably became lost along the way. We all assumed that it was because we were spiritual dunces and he knew what he was taking about. The problem must be with our understanding because, after all, he was Dr. Hoeh.

He speculated and pontificated over really smart things, like figuring out prophecy: Who was the Beast and when was America going to collapse and what would we all do in caves in Petra. We all felt swell knowing Dr. Hoeh was working on these very things at the highest levels and all those deep thoughts were going to pay off when persecution came.

As an aside, somewhere along the way I picked up a musty copy of Volume 2 of The Compendium (published in 1963). Despite the blessing of having had this rare and worthy tome in my library for years (filed next to the infamous Systematic Theology Project), I confess that it remains a largely unread curiosity. Sections of the legendary dissertation proudly bear titles like: "Hu the Mighty", Kings of Cruithne Continued, Whites Did Not Become Indians, Ogus Khan, Sicambrian Kings, Dynasty of Stenkil, The Jorhamites of Hejaz, Do Miracles Happen Today? and The Sin of Cain and Geology.

 

Update Archives

Updates for August - October 2001

Email: missingdimension@yahoo.com

 

 

Click Here!